Re:California lawmaker pushes to tax online sales
by rbritton on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:19PM
(#2122626)
I disagree. I believe you should only have to collect sales tax in and for the jurisdiction where you do business (i.e., the city/county/state combo). Washington state changed how they require sales tax a couple years ago and now charges sales tax based on where you _ship_ the end product. Out-of-state is zero as in every other state, but in-state is where it gets miserable. The table the department of revenue publishes has something like 150000 rows where, to get an accurate sales tax jurisdiction code and rate, you have to look up by the full Zip+4. Remittance monthly/quarterly/annually requires YOU to do all the work of breaking it out by jurisdiction. With any volume at all it's absolutely miserable.
Re:California lawmaker pushes to tax online sales
by ericd on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:25PM
(#2122643)
Yeah, unless the federal government manages the coordination of maintaining an easily accessible nationwide database of these varying tax rates, or there's a mandate that the state tax code and collection be vastly simplified for online stores, I think this is likely to smother small e-commerce companies and discourage new ones from starting up.
Re:California lawmaker pushes to tax online sales
by kgermino on Thursday January 20, 2011 @10:32AM
(#2123926)
I still think that paying sales tax _only_ in the district where the business is based isn't right either because when a company gets large enough (Think Walmart) that's a ton of money going to one town. However I don't see why you can't tax based on where the product is shipped from, or the closest company office to the buyer. That's no worse than a company that has stores in different districts and spreads the revenue closer to what it would actually be in a retail store.
Re:California lawmaker pushes to tax online sales
by anamax on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:56AM
(#2122832)
> I agree that businesses should be required to collect some sort of sales tax, although I'm not entirely sure how. It's one thing to say that businesses have to collect sales taxes for the state the product is shipped to but what about local sales taxes?
It's not just variation by geography, but variation by product.
Different things are subject to sales tax in different jurisdictions.
Another option is to charge the tax based on where the company is based, or better yet tax based on the district that the warehouse or store that the item is shipped from is located. I.E. if you buy something from amazon.com and they ship it from their warehouse in Madison WI (not sure if there is one there, just an example) then your purchase is taxed as if you drove to Madison and bought it. This is still relatively complicated but I believe that it is the best solution, especially since it's closest to what would happen if you drove to a store. However I haven't put much thought into it so please let me know about any problems you see or better ideas.