News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by bitcurious on Friday October 11, 2019 @07:29AM (#21223299)
The reason this article was written was because Wired paid a journalist to peruse a bunch of academic journals looking for interesting stuff. If you cut Wired out from the profit loop, you’d have to read those academic journals yourself, or depend on other users on this website to do it. I don’t see either happening reliably enough to compete with a paid professional.
Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by catalogia on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:01PM (#21225618)
Look at the hyperlinks in the Wired article:

https://www.bls.gov/ooh/transportation-and-material-moving/w...

https://www.wired.com/story/no-more-screen-time-navy-reverts...

https://www.washington.edu/news/2017/09/07/ship-exhaust-make...

https://www.wired.com/story/cleaner-ships-more-expensive-hol...

https://www.wired.com/story/cleaner-ships-more-expensive-hol...

Five links, three back to their own site, two away from their site. But none of them link to the academic paper! This is totally unacceptable. Is this not the web, aren't hyperlinks the most basic tool we have when creating the web? Aren't hyperlinks what make the "web" a web in the first place? So why then do media organizations refuse to use them properly?

(Sometimes they have the excuse of "not wanting to send precious eyeballs to somebody else's site" which I don't think is an excuse that should be tolerated but isn't even relevant here since they did include two links that leave Wired.)

I don't think we should be rewarding this sort of gatekeeping behavior. This isn't a one time fluke. Refusing to link to source material even though it's available on the web is the status quo for scientific journalism in particular. It's gatekeeping, and shouldn't be accepted as the status quo.

Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by basch on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:26AM (#21224098)
It's really time for hn to acknowledge that stories have multiple links, perspectives, and chronological events and allow groupings. Take techmeme for example https://www.techmeme.com/191010/p17#a191010p17

To the left of the story, click the down arrow, thats every repost or perspective of the original story. Then the indented stories are followups.

Circa also designed itself around this, having a story and when you clicked it, THEN you would see the overall structure of the stories development timeline.

It wouldnt even have to be a chance to the existing hn site, somuch as an additional view that allows stories and comments to be stitched together and intermixed.

More on the topic of this post, I love the wired headline, how it reads "lightening strikes twice" and then the sentence continues, modifying twice into "twice as."

Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by fedups on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:02AM (#21224429)
Never heard about Circa before, but just read a little about them and their feature that has the goal

> "to break down a story into its core elements: facts, stats, quotes and media", as opposed to a summary where content is reduced for quicker reading or users are linked elsewhere for the full story

Do you know of any other [general, not tech-specific] media outlets with this philosophy? I find most sources these days are unhelpful even though they think they're adding value with emphasis on narratives.

Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by basch on Friday October 11, 2019 @12:56PM (#21226169)
it flies in the face of "chronological feed culture" (twitter, rivers) and "algo popularity" to have people clicking the same story multiple time for updates. chron/ai feeds are meant to let you ever feast on the new without ever going back to the old. that philosophy you are looking for has a hard time competing with out of context constantly breaking news blips. (short answer to your q, I cant think of a good one off the top of my head.) Does wikinews have that sort of metastructure above stories? https://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Main_Page

personally id love a menu in a news app that says "updates to stories youve clicked" without having to follow a story. then separately i would have "followed/starred" stories as a different menu entry. they might sort differently, such as, since last clicked vs since most recent update.

Re:Lightning Strikes Twice as Much over Shipping Lanes by nyolfen on Friday October 11, 2019 @03:25PM (#21227575)
i can nearly guarantee you that the “journalist” found it on twitter just like the rest of us