News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:07PM (#2122070)
> Who says infinity is a number?

Not I:

> Oh, or is it maybe a confusion with infinity, which, if we were to try to classify it, would have some claim to being both?

… although the old maxim “What's a number?” “Whatever you treat as a number” (which I encountered in Linderholm's wonderful book (http://www.amazon.com/Mathematics-made-difficult-Carl-Linder...) ) means that the various flavours of infinity, considered as ordinals or cardinals, have some claim to being numbers; and it is often helpful in measure theory, and my own work, to treat even plain old infinity as being a number on at least as good a footing as any other (positive real).

> Once we are confident that infinity is not a number, why would we expect it to have parity?

Why not?

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by ezalor on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:11PM (#2122086)
Parity is a property of numbers and sets only. Or do you think infinity is a set?
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:38PM (#2122168)
> Parity is a property of numbers and sets only.

Why? Seriously, though: what do you mean by parity (EDIT: I mean even-ness) of a set? Almost assuredly, something like “it can be partitioned into two disjoint subsets that can be put into bijection”; but then you've just defined even-ness of cardinals (which are sets after all), and all infinite cardinals are even (in fact, satisfy 2κ = κ; EDIT: and odd; they also satisfy 2κ + 1 = κ).

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by ezalor on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:48PM (#2122191)
You read my mind for "parity of a set". So Q.E.D.: parity is only applicable to reason about numbers (and infinity is not a number). See also surreal numbers.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by wnoise on Thursday January 20, 2011 @03:09AM (#2123050)
> Parity is a property of numbers and sets only.

It's a property of _integers_, or any system with a natural homorphism into the integers mod 2 under addition. It's certainly not a property of numbers in general. Is pi even or odd? How about sqrt(2) + i*e?