News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @07:39PM (#2121988)
I think the confusion is simple. They believe that an even number is 2n, but think about n over the naturals. Often they'll also be confused about -1.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by ionfish on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:08PM (#2122078)
This wouldn't be a problem if people would stop thinking that the natural numbers start at 1.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:15PM (#2122091)
That's probably the most popular way it is taught. And whole numbers starting at 0. Although oddly some people will learn in the complete opposite way.

We could just throw away these short hands and just integers, positive integers, negative integers.

Which actually led me to another potential reason for the confusion. Is zero positive or negative? OK, now is zero even or odd? I can imagine some just see zero with weird properties.

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by ionfish on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:28PM (#2122136)

    We could just throw away these short hands and just [use]
    integers, positive integers, negative integers.
This depends on who you consider "we" to be. If we're talking about computer programmers, in most languages integers are all you get: natural numbers aren't available (although the Haskell community want them [1]).

On the other hand, from the perspective of mathematics, the natural numbers are very different to the integers. For one thing, they're wellordered whereas the integers are not. Obviously a set-theoretic definition of the natural numbers (as the finite ordinals) will start at 0 since it's just identified with ø. Set-theoretic definitions of the integers are typically in terms of equivalence classes of pairs of natural numbers (or arbitrary elements from these equivalence classes if you want to work in ACA0) [2].

[1] http://hackage.haskell.org/trac/haskell-prime/wiki/Natural

[2] See SoSOA p.10 for details. http://www.math.psu.edu/simpson/sosoa/

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:53PM (#2122212)
> Is zero positive or negative? OK, now is zero even or odd? I can imagine some just see zero with weird properties.

I think that's the best explanation I've heard. Thanks! (Also you can't divide by it (although (http://www.bbc.co.uk/berkshire/content/articles/2006/12/06/d...) …), so who knows what trickery it's up to?)

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:08PM (#2122075)
> Often they'll also be confused about -1.

Hmm, I've never encountered that—which is not to say you're wrong. I'll bet you'd have a hard time finding someone post-secondary school who wouldn't answer instantly that -2 was even, though.

Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:18PM (#2122104)
You must not be from the US. Ask random adult on the street if 2,229 is even or odd. I think you might be surprised at how many people get that wrong. Not that I've ever done it, but I suspect that you'll get at least a couple in ten who don't know.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:35PM (#2122156)
Indeed I am from the US. I guess I would be surprised to hear people get that one wrong, but I'd be truly shocked to see someone get the classification of -2 wrong.

(A disclaimer: The only people with whom I've had occasion to have this conversation have been students in (my) college mathematics classes, so I guess I should clarify that these are the people of whom I'm really thinking.)