Re:The Rich Do Pay Higher Taxes Than You
by refurb on Thursday October 10, 2019 @07:03PM
(#21220075)
Maybe.
Another thing that jumped out to me is why the top 400? Why not 500? Why not 100? 400 is an odd number to choose.
We know the very top earners tend to be cases of windfalls. You sell your company, you offload all your shares, you sell a ton of land. Those can have odd tax implications.
My guess is that they cherry picked the top 400 because it supported their conclusion. And the tax rates were a 1-off event that doesn’t normally happen.
How are you commenting on something like this without knowing about Forbes 400? Are you serious?
Huh? The Forbes 400 have a number of non-Americans on the list. They don't pay US taxes at all.
And doing a study where you look at the top 400 because "Forbes has a list of 400" makes zero sense.
Hack job!
Nope, 400 is strictly Americans, and was released a week ago. I give up.
And most of the piece is spent arguing against something somewhere between an aside and a strawman, then towards the end they admit as much(!), but have nothing substantial to add.
Whether your gut agrees with the "message", rhetorically it's just really awful.