Both definitions are actually useful in different contexts. The second one certainly allows for more flexibility in growth and development. whatwg is recognizing that HTML, like chrome, isn't as important in a particular ordinal identifier, as they are in the features they offer and the development model behind them.
I'm guessing 95% of the people using chrome don't what version they are currently using - but it has never impacted web developers, or users, from making use of the browser.
It also aligns with agile development practices, and, if I can stretch a bit, dvcsystems - people are free to complete new stories in the HTML definition or browser, without worrying too much about other teams work, or particular releases.
I think these last 2 announcements have drastically helped clarify things. So as a web enthusiast I do find it great
w3c releasing an HTML 5 logo and the whatwg renaming HTML 5 to HTML doesn't sound that great.