Re:Science papers are getting harder to read (2017)
by dekhn on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @04:12PM
(#21207457)
in my experience, the best papers are written by people who are not part of the academic incentive system.
We had a problem at UC Berkeley where a very smart CS guy wanted to publish a paper but since he didn't have an official affiliation, major journals wouldn't publish his papers (they literally wouldn't publish a paper by a person whose correspondence address was their home address).
So we gave him a title at Berkeley and the paper was published.
His work is some of the best around, but the academic community wouldn't pay attention until he ran some benchmarks and had them disseminated by prominent academics.
Re:Science papers are getting harder to read (2017)
by siliconshinobi on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:49AM
(#21204309)
Do you have an academic and/or industry background? I'd be curious to hear about what the experience of publishing in an academic journal as outsider was like.
Re:Science papers are getting harder to read (2017)
by xamuel on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @12:05PM
(#21204503)
I'm a math PhD, left academia because I have kids and I wanted to give them a better life than you can give kids with a postdoc salary ;) I can't perceive any differences as an outsider vs. insider. Probably some reviewers subconsciously let it influence their judgment, but at least in some fields you can publish in double-blind reviewed journals where your identity is hidden from the reviewers.
[1] https://philarchive.org/archive/ALEATO-6 "A type of simulation which some experimental evidence suggests we don't live in"