Re:The Myth of Female Software Developers
by jerf on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:40AM
(#2120316)
"Dislikes working with computers" is a new argument you just made; the article cited "Working with computers is a "solitary" activity which attracts more men than women", IT is not particularly a solitary activity in practice. Not like programming can be, though the solitariness seems overstated to me there too. It doesn't do anything to disprove the assertion that there is something about programming particularly distasteful to women, the real argument. (Which I am neither advancing nor attacking here.)
Like I said, all this article "showed" was a reiteration that there are "no" women in programming. You can't get to causation from there.
Besides, if you're going to argue that because women go into IT you can disprove some things, you need to take it all the way, not just use it to prove a couple of pet points then run away from the other implications, like the fact that there are obviously no systematic barriers to women in IT, and it seems rather unlikely to me that there are systematic barriers to programming occupations that don't exist in IT. Certainly I'd like to see one demonstrated rather than asserted if it's going to be the core of your argument. So using this same data we can plausibly argue that the data shows that there is something about programming that women legitimately of their own free will prefer on average not to do.
This is not the argument I am advancing; if I were I'd be refining it a lot more. My point for this post is that there mere fact that I can use this data in favor of such an argument is proof that the data proves nothing. It's not enough. (Trying to disprove the previous paragraph in a reply would be entirely missing my point.)
Like I said, all this article "showed" was a reiteration that there are "no" women in programming. You can't get to causation from there.
Besides, if you're going to argue that because women go into IT you can disprove some things, you need to take it all the way, not just use it to prove a couple of pet points then run away from the other implications, like the fact that there are obviously no systematic barriers to women in IT, and it seems rather unlikely to me that there are systematic barriers to programming occupations that don't exist in IT. Certainly I'd like to see one demonstrated rather than asserted if it's going to be the core of your argument. So using this same data we can plausibly argue that the data shows that there is something about programming that women legitimately of their own free will prefer on average not to do.
This is not the argument I am advancing; if I were I'd be refining it a lot more. My point for this post is that there mere fact that I can use this data in favor of such an argument is proof that the data proves nothing. It's not enough. (Trying to disprove the previous paragraph in a reply would be entirely missing my point.)