News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by spiffworks on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:29AM (#2120265)
The webm spec is frozen, and all patents are irrevocably licensed. Webm is not 'controlled' by Google.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:01PM (#2120405)
They're not irrevcably licensed. If you find that WebM does actually violate your patents you can't sue otherwise you lose your license to all of the other patents.

Realistically Google should not revoke your licenses unless you lose the lawsuit (not when filed), because if they have legitimately infringed your patent then it seems like blackmail to keep them from acting on it by such a method.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by spiffworks on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:15PM (#2120452)
You're quite right, but I think its ridiculous to ask Google to give you a free license to their patents even as you are suing them for infringing yours.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:56PM (#2120608)
They're the ones pushing that this be the defactor standard for web video. If that's the case then they shouldn't attempt to block a party from exercising their patent rights by effectively threatening that if they do so they won't have any access to video on the web.

Could you imagine MS saying in their Windows license agreement saying that they can revoke your licenses if you sue them over a patent?

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by archangel_one on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @04:20PM (#2121317)
Yes, I can imagine that quite clearly. It wouldn't be the most repressive clause in that license agreement.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @04:38PM (#2121366)
AFACT there is no clause in the Windows license that MS could invoke that would prevent you from entering a complete industry.

Google's position is literally... screw with us, and if WebM catches on, you can't do video on the internet.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by vetinari on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @04:58PM (#2121433)
And that's why nobody sane will try to screw with them. Nobody wants to lose the ability to do video on the internet during next 20 (plus/minus) years.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by kenjackson on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @05:04PM (#2121455)
And that doesn't bother you? They're basically saying, "We may have stolen your technology... oh well, it's ours now. We run the internet."

I guess as long as Google is pushing the technology that "you" like they can do no evil.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by vetinari on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @05:44PM (#2121580)
That "We may have stolen your technology" is pushing it.

Google did due diligence before buying On2 with VP8. They did patent search. If anyone appears now with some patent claim against VP8, suing left and right users of VP8, it does not show good faith on their part.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by sudont on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:41AM (#2120320)
The patent thing is just FUD by Apple proponents. But, I won't support WebM until it's an ISO standard, frozen is just a promise at this point.

Their own site says "dedicated to developing a high-quality..." which, taken literally, means that the project is still underway. Also listed on the front page: "Submit patches and improvements" Yet again, saying that it's a work in progress.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:56AM (#2120374)
The encoder is being improved, and the decoder is being optimised for speed on various platforms but the spec defines what the decoder does and it was effectively frozen as soon as Google converted a bunch of Youtube videos and got hardware manufacturers on board. Any change to the format would break existing content (most of Youtube) and shipping hardware.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by bryanlarsen on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:57AM (#2120380)
The fact that the standard is frozen is not incompatible with them improving their implementation.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by ootachi on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @12:22PM (#2120487)
ISO leads something to be desired: witness the glacial pace of C++0x (now C++1x). I'd prefer some standardization of VP8 - don't get me wrong - but going through ISO would likely be a mistake.
Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by othermaciej on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @01:53PM (#2120788)
I think you are wrong to project the failings of the C++ committee on ISO as a whole.

For H.264/AVC, it was less than 4 years from the first draft to final ratification. It was a joint effort of ISO and ITU-T.

Still, if that's too slow, SMPTE seems to go faster when they start with an existing codec. VC-1 and VC-2 (a profile of Dirac) were both done there.

Re:No double standards: supporting Google's push for WebM by yuhong on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @03:14PM (#2121070)
BTW, there is an effect at ISO to do a royalty-free ("Option 1") MPEG: http://www.robglidden.com/tag/mpeg/