Re:How Much Money Do Parking Lots Make?
by coldtea on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @08:16AM
(#21202417)
One might as well ask "Why make people pay taxes on income they worked to make?".
There's no some god-given justification for taxes.
We have them because:
a) somebody can enforce their payment
b) societies need a money pool to do public things
c) societies need to encourage/discourage some things
A country could opt not to have taxes, and not maintain an army for example, and live it to the goodwill of the citizens to build infrastructure. That couldn't would be stomped by one that did have taxes and used them to build a good army. So that doesn't work out that good...
Now, assuming a society decide it needs taxes, what taxes to have is more a question of "how much money are needed" and "how to present it nicely" and "what to encourage/discourage".
Regarding "how much money is needed", the justification for property tax is simple: if income tax money aren't enough, governments might add not just property tax, but even a breathing tax. On the plus side, property is difficult to hide (as money would be e.g. in the Kayman islands).
Regarding "what to discourage", the justification for property tax is, not to hog down property and prevent its use.
You also want to get some of the value the community/government creates in an area and pushes property values (not just market value, but also use-value, like having a school nearby) up back.
There's no some god-given justification for taxes.
We have them because:
a) somebody can enforce their payment
b) societies need a money pool to do public things
c) societies need to encourage/discourage some things
A country could opt not to have taxes, and not maintain an army for example, and live it to the goodwill of the citizens to build infrastructure. That couldn't would be stomped by one that did have taxes and used them to build a good army. So that doesn't work out that good...
Now, assuming a society decide it needs taxes, what taxes to have is more a question of "how much money are needed" and "how to present it nicely" and "what to encourage/discourage".
Regarding "how much money is needed", the justification for property tax is simple: if income tax money aren't enough, governments might add not just property tax, but even a breathing tax. On the plus side, property is difficult to hide (as money would be e.g. in the Kayman islands).
Regarding "what to discourage", the justification for property tax is, not to hog down property and prevent its use.
You also want to get some of the value the community/government creates in an area and pushes property values (not just market value, but also use-value, like having a school nearby) up back.