News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Formats, no Format Wars by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @05:25AM (#2119370)
I believe this was the original plan for Xiph's Vorbis, for similar reasons. I believe they abandoned it because of practicality but I can't Google up a link to where I originally read about this. I seem to recall it also involved Monty doing a demo for some company (Apple?) where they thought he was mental to suggest such a thing.

edit: http://www.systemtoolbox.com/bfarticle.php?content_id=6

Monty: The previous Ogg generation, Stormbringer, was a "meta-codec", a language and virtual machine for writing other codecs. It turns out very few people at the time were interested; they didn't want meta-codecs, they wanted the codecs themselves. A particularly abysmal demo of Stormbringer at Apple finally drove that point home (in addition to the fact that Apple was uninterested in Stormbringer, which needed more work to be practically useful, our demo laptop decided to overheat and break down in the middle of our pitch to the Quicktime group). That took our sense of direction away for a while; for most of 1998, no one worked on anything related to Ogg.

Then in the fall, Fraunhofer decided to start cracking down on free encoder implementations of mp3. That worried me. It also seemed like things were only likely to get worse; the trend was clearly for companies to start "cashing in" on the Net any way possible, often involving the basic technology itself, and it looked like digital audio would be no different. In 1998 this sense of foreboding was mostly a vague suspicion, but the trend strengthened and clarified over time. That gave me a clear direction to begin Vorbis; I knew what the world was going to need in a codec and soon.

There are no comments on this comment yet.