News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by busterarm on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:10PM (#21187356)
-ISIS. At their peak they had a sizeable chunk of land, a flag, a capital, civic functions like a court system, an oil industry, handed out passports, were fighting a conventional land war using conventional (not terrorist/guerilla) tactics, had a uniformed army, and the word "state" was right there in the name. But don't you dare call them a state lest someone mistake you for a terrorist sympathizer.

That's playing a bit fast and loose with the facts there. ISIS conducted public executions, crucifixions, desecration of cultural sites and enslaved people for a labor force. That's textbook asymmetric warfare/terrorism.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by jdoliner on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:15PM (#21187379)
> That's playing a bit fast and loose with the facts there. ISIS conducted public executions, crucifixions, desecration of cultural sites and enslaved people for a labor force. That's textbook asymmetric warfare/terrorism.

To me that just sounds like textbook nationhood. The defining feature of the state is having the monopoly on violence within its borders.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by jlokier on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:44PM (#21187884)
I think the question of treating ISIS territory as an independent state, with all the international law that would imply about respecting its independence and autonomy, treating it as a peer at the UN, etc., is a textbook case of why (international-legal) legitimacy is a status not granted automatically in the basis of territory and control alone, and should not be.

The things ISIS members did to subpopulations people within that territory were almost universally condemned across the world as large-scale serious human abuse, and the territories were obtained through quite recent violence from other nations whose administrative borders had not stopped being recognised internationally.

So I think it was widely regarded that ISIS should not be granted the international respect and autonomy of legal recognition, nor should it keep any power it had of a monopoly on violence within its borders (or any borders).

That's not to say there aren't widely condemned things going on in other countries. But there is a kind of collective, sometimes grudging, but systematised respect for the autonomy of countries as nations, which I think was widely regarded as not something that would be right to grant to ISIS (or take away from the nations that ISIS had taken territory from).

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by IIAOPSW on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:47AM (#21189440)
>as an independent state, with all the international law that would imply about respecting its independence and autonomy.

The UN absolutely has provisions in its charter for approved wars. The Korean war was UN approved. A regime that is violent against civilians and outwardly genocidal towards religious minorities like ISIS is exactly the situation UN approved intervention was made for (designed with the Nazi's in mind).

I reject the premise that calling them a state would entail granting them anything.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by opportune on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:51PM (#21187589)
Saudi Arabia also does all of the things you listed, except perhaps desecration of cultural sites. Just because a country does things you don’t like doesn’t make it not a country
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by busterarm on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:13PM (#21187717)
I wasn't arguing that, I was just calling out the parent for saying ISIS didn't use terrorism as a tactic.

Nice whataboutism there though.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by dkersten on Monday October 07, 2019 @10:06PM (#21187982)
> I was just calling out the parent for saying ISIS didn't use terrorism as a tactic.

Where did they say this? I don't see anything about ISIS not using terrorism as a tactic, just that if you recognize ISIS as a state, you get called a terrorist sympathizer. Besides, plenty of countries use terrorist tactics when at war, unfortunately.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by opportune on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:17PM (#21187742)
How is it whataboutism? Your criteria for being a country also apply to Saudi Arabia, which anybody would generally accept to be a country.

If I say a square is any four sided object with equal sides, is a rhombus whataboutism?

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by voldacar on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:19PM (#21187402)
> ISIS conducted public executions, crucifixions, desecration of cultural sites and enslaved people for a labor force.

you mean things which "recognized" states do all the time?

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by kerkeslager on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:09AM (#21188945)
> ISIS conducted public executions, crucifixions, desecration of cultural sites and enslaved people for a labor force. That's textbook asymmetric warfare/terrorism.

The US has done all of these except crucifixions. Arguably, we've done all of them (except crucifixion) within the last decade. I'm not sure we can claim "not crucifying" as moral high ground when Americans did things like the following (warning: what follows is horrifying):

"He was chained by his neck and dragged out of the county court by observers. He was then paraded through the street, all while being stabbed and beaten, before being held down and castrated. He was then lynched in front of Waco's city hall."

"Over 10,000 spectators, including city officials and police, gathered to watch the attack. There was a celebratory atmosphere among whites at the spectacle murder, and many children attended during their lunch hour. Members of the mob cut off his fingers, and hung him over a bonfire after saturating him with coal oil. He was repeatedly lowered and raised over the fire for about two hours. After the fire was extinguished, his charred torso was dragged through the town and parts of his body were sold as souvenirs. A professional photographer took pictures as the event unfolded, providing rare imagery of a lynching in progress. The pictures were printed and sold as postcards in Waco."[1]

This happened in 1916--most would consider the US to have been a nation for over a century by this point.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_of_Jesse_Washington

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by all2 on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:59PM (#21187940)
You've just described the Roman Empire to a <T>.

(Is that generic type notation?)

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by IIAOPSW on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:22PM (#21187426)
Was the Roman Empire a country?
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by qwerty456127 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @11:53AM (#21215945)
Not really, it was the alpha version of the EU.
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by busterarm on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:26PM (#21187451)
Thankfully many international treaties have been made in the last few thousand years and civilized nations wage war differently now. I was expressly disputing the parent poster's claim that ISIS did not use terrorist tactics, which is a statement I find difficult for anyone to really take issue with.
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by harimau777 on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:56PM (#21187625)
While I think it's clear that ISIS was/is evil, I'm not sure that its as clear that those actions (or at least all of them) were terrorism.

I'd define terrorism as something along the lines of "using guerrilla tactics against civilian targets in order to achieve political ends". I would differentiate that from atrocities committed against a state's own people in order to keep them in line (for example Stalin's purges), human rights violations (e.g. witch trials or killing homosexuals), ethnic/religious cleansing, or guerrilla attacks against targets with legitimate strategic value.

My understanding, although I am definitely not super informed on this, is that ISIS's atrocities were mostly keeping people in line, human rights abuse, and religious cleansing. Therefore I would not consider those acts to be terrorism. However, that doesn't make them any less evil.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by CydeWeys on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:04PM (#21187665)
Whether a state uses terrorist tactics is orthogonal to the issue of it being a state. Was the Russian shooting down of MH-17 not a terrorist act undertaken by a state? How about the bombing of the Beirut barracks? How about any number of acts by Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, or Imperial Japan?
Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by busterarm on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:12PM (#21187712)
Sure, I won't even dispute that. What I'm disputing is that the parent poster said that ISIS did not use terrorist tactics.

That is blatantly a false statement. I can't believe the negative reaction towards pointing that out.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by skissane on Monday October 07, 2019 @10:09PM (#21187996)
What they said was ISIS "were fighting a conventional land war using conventional (not terrorist/guerilla) tactics"

You are summarising that as "ISIS did not use terrorist tactics"

I think that is a misleading summary. I don't think the poster meant to dispute that ISIS was behind terrorist attacks, both in the Middle East and also in other parts of the world. What they were saying, is that ISIS was engaging in conventional (non-terrorist) military operations against the Syrian and Iraqi governments, other rebel groups, etc. Terrorism and conventional military tactics are not mutually exclusive, one can pursue both strategies at the same time. But the second strategy is a sign that one is dealing with something having de facto statehood, as opposed to a non-state terrorist group.

If you are getting heavily down-voted, a possible explanation is that people perceive you to be engaging in an uncharitable reading of the remarks you are responding to

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by busterarm on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:58PM (#21188630)
> If you are getting heavily down-voted, a possible explanation is that people perceive you to be engaging in an uncharitable reading of the remarks you are responding to

If they wanted to say that ISIS was using conventional _AND_ terrorist tactics that would be one thing. They specifically said "not". You even quoted.

If my options are either to stay silent or charitably read someone's claim that ISIS' tactics don't meet their definition of the word terrorism, because they're a state, then honestly I don't want an account on this site anymore.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by gfdgsgaagrhstrs on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @03:09PM (#21195921)
You're getting some negative reaction because you're missing the points OP was making.

1) At points, they were waging a war that did not rely on terrorist/guerrilla tactics. OP did not claim they don't do 'terrorist stuff' at all. Waging conventional war requires control of territory, which is why this is important.

2) Saying ISIS is/controls a state would have you labeled as a terrorist sympathizer in the media or in conversation. This demonstrates that calling something a 'state' has an implicit moral connotation in popular culture. OP is arguing this should not be true.

None of OPs points were a _moral_ judgement of ISIS. I think we can all agree ISIS is bad.

For instance, I strongly believe Palestine should be an independent, free state distinct from Israel. However, the UN _recognizing_ it as a state does not mean it magically becomes one. The UN is just making a political point, but sadly one that has little impact on the reality in Palestine.

Re:Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong by IIAOPSW on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:20PM (#21198355)
Thank you. This is exactly what I was getting at.