Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by Schoolmeister on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:59AM
(#21178173)
Okay. But who gets to define what constitutes a criminal?
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by bayesian_horse on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:18AM
(#21178272)
In the particular case of US jurisdiction, and many other Western democracies, that is defined by the applicable laws as issued by the legislature.
There is no better way to define "criminal", despite all the shortcomings.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by bayesian_horse on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:59AM
(#21178172)
Facebook is not giving over text messages of average users to law enforcement, so far. It still requires due process for LEAs to get that data or to do anything with it.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by cameronbrown on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:55AM
(#21178157)
I beg to differ. I actually don't mind targeted ads, but I do have a massive problem with Facebook giving that data to the government.
> Free speech in the US is pretty limitless, up to the point that such speech infringes on the rights of other people or endangers them.
The US Constitution explicitly makes calls to violence illegal.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by SamReidHughes on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:11AM
(#21178234)
> The US Constitution explicitly makes calls to violence illegal.
Um, no it most certainly does not.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by cameronbrown on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:17AM
(#21178266)
Okay, more like calls to violence aren't protected free speech.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by icebraining on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:44AM
(#21178393)
The text of the US constitution has no explicit exceptions to first amendment, those were introduced by the supreme court upon interpretation of the purpose of the amendment.
Re:Open Letter from Governments to Facebook Is an All-Out At...
by SamReidHughes on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:44AM
(#21178391)
Yes, in fact, they are. Under the current state of jurisprudence.
The only benefit to an average user is that no Facebook employee can look at your text messages. Law enforcement agencies don't look at text messages of average users, and even in the collect-everything scenarios, they don't take notice of virtually anyone, on average.
It's really mostly the criminals that benefit disproportionally from default encryption in facebook messages.
From the perspective of US law, you might not want LEAs to read your text messages, but even if they could, they can't do anything about it even up to threatening them. Free speech in the US is pretty limitless, up to the point that such speech infringes on the rights of other people or endangers them.