News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by thethirdone on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:00PM (#21176962)
I would recommend Opus Magnum over TIS-100 even for people on this site. Its the result of the Zachatronics formula having time to grow after SpaceChem.

The main reason I personally prefer Opus Magnum is that solving the levels is easy, but optimizing is challenging and rewarding. TIS-100 on the other hand has a higher difficulty to initially solve the puzzles and optimization becomes a little bit of a guessing game. Also having only 3 saved solutions per level makes it hard to optimize without losing past solutions.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by LEARAX on Monday October 07, 2019 @01:41AM (#21177871)
Personally, I found Opus Magnum far too easy. In TIS-100, the constraints are brutal, and I often made multiple attempts before I was successful. In Opus Magnum, I finished every puzzle on my first try. You have almost no constraints. While optimizing is still a challenge, it felt much less rewarding to me. I feel no compulsion to return to OM after finishing the main campaign, but I return to TIS-100 every few months or so to mess around with the harder puzzles.

The 3 saved puzzles is a bit annoying, but you can always backup the puzzle files since they're just text.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by yvdriess on Monday October 07, 2019 @04:23AM (#21178568)
That was by design in Opus Magnum. The game is still brutally hard by sticking to the (self-imposed) constraints, but it wants to open up to a much broader audience. Celeste follows the same designed approach to difficulty.

Related RPS article: https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2018/02/27/what-works-and-w...

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by thethirdone on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:51AM (#21178426)
> In Opus Magnum, I finished every puzzle on my first try.

I never was close to failing to finish a puzzle in OM. It was just a matter of how poor my solution performed whatever metric I chose to optimize first. The puzzles at the end of the campaign had me "give up" and settle for an ugly slow solution though.

> I feel no compulsion to return to OM after finishing the main campaign

If you haven't tried the Journal puzzles in OM, I would recommend you give them a shot. Many of them are in confined spaces rather than an infinite plane. I have yet to find a puzzle as hard as the ones in the TIS-NET directory, but they are a step up from the rest of the OM puzzles in terms of difficulty.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by Shish2k on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:58PM (#21183131)
I find the OM approach to be much more fun when you have friends to compete with - "Making a solution is easy" opens it up to a lot more people, but "Making a GOOD solution is hard" makes it great for competitive play.

(Or even without friends, like me, I just refused to proceed to the next level until I was in the global top 1% for the current level :P)

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by Waterluvian on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:04PM (#21176984)
SpaceChem is like this too. Even I could beat almost all the levels. And then I watch this tournament on YouTube and remember that some people are Flippin geniuses.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL0PcDuxlam1bDnEfuT15R... (skip to "Week 1 Results" and watch the rest of thr Playlist. It's fascinating stuff. Seriously. Watch.)

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by thethirdone on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:11PM (#21177017)
I haven't played completely through SpaceChem so I don't actually know how hard it gets.

I lost my save for the game and the UI is frustrating enough I don't want to slog through the early levels when I haven't optimized the newer Zachatronics games to my satisfaction.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by panic on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:23AM (#21178015)
What I love about Opus Magnum is how cool the solutions look. Optimized assembly code can be satisfying to write, but it'll never have the visual appeal of a tightly-designed alchemical machine.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by yvdriess on Monday October 07, 2019 @04:28AM (#21178598)
And they totally know this, going so far as to offer an 'export to gif' option at the end of the puzzle.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by FPGAhacker on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:52AM (#21178141)
I second that. I do like tis-100 as much or more, but the visuals in opus magnum are mesmerizing.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by dancek on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:30AM (#21178337)
A matter of taste, probably. I love every other game by Zachtronics except Opus Magnum. With TIS-100 the clear favorite.

Somehow the highly geometrical puzzles don't give me a feeling of achievement. They're not very interesting but do become quite difficult towards the end. But of course many other people just love them.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by billfruit on Monday October 07, 2019 @05:29AM (#21178909)
I find myself somewhat bothered by the totally bogus chemistry in the opus magnum, and spacechem. If they could get the chemistry aleast sound believable it would be more fun.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by egypturnash on Monday October 07, 2019 @05:43AM (#21179001)
It’s not chemistry. It’s alchemy.

Video game cartoon alchemy, but still: not video game cartoon chemistry. There is a difference.

Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by PhasmaFelis on Monday October 07, 2019 @10:44AM (#21181435)
That works for Opus Magnum, but SpaceChem has a very clear sci-fi presentation to it, so it's confusing.
Re:Zachtronics: Ten Years of Terrible Games (2017) [video] by billfruit on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:08AM (#21179819)
Yes I thought spacechem was about chemistry not alchemy.