News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Journalist says CBP withheld passport until he agreed he ... by jacquesm on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:03PM (#21174701)
I agree that all news is biased. But fake scandals and other non-news is more present in some feeds than others. And once you realize that there is always bias you can at least to some extent attempt to correct for that. Mandatory reading in this context is 'Manufacturing consent'.

But even given all that negative sentiment a solid free press is a good thing and should be protected.

Re:Journalist says CBP withheld passport until he agreed he ... by repolfx on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:56AM (#21182375)
But even given all that negative sentiment a solid free press is a good thing and should be protected.

Yes it is, but I haven't seen people like this CBP officer suggest that the solution to their concerns is taking away press freedoms.

This officer clearly believes that the "free press" is a theory, not something they observe in practice. That is, the underlying assumption is that if the press is free to attack the government then it always will, whereas what he actually perceives is that the press is virtually the same as one party of government and will only .. as a whole .. attack the other side, not their own.

And he's right. Only 7% of US journalists claimed to vote Republican in 2014:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/05/06/ju...

Most journalists claim to be independent, but you wouldn't know it from their output. How many newspapers opted to back nobody in the 2016 election? And how many backed Trump? IIRC it was "none" and "all of them".

The press have made their bed, now they're lying in it. Trust in them has been in freefall for a long time, especially amongst Republicans, who this CBP officer most surely was. And they deserve this lack of trust. I routinely read stories in the press that are blatantly false, and always in support of the same political narrative. Why should anyone feel strongly about the freedom of the press when they have come out in strong support of a particular political ideology? That isn't what freedom of the press is meant to be about.

Re:Journalist says CBP withheld passport until he agreed he ... by Simulacra on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:28PM (#21174885)
The media seems to think along the lines: if it generates revenue, then its fit to print. Until traditional news media can stand on its own again, absent corporate largess, it will not be free and independent.
Re:Journalist says CBP withheld passport until he agreed he ... by jacquesm on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:34PM (#21174920)
Think of 'the media' as more than one person acting with different motivations. On the one hand there are the commercial people, they try to generate revenues, if possible to pay out to the owners but at any rate enough to keep the lights on. This will generate a drive to monetize and is to a large extent responsible for the trivial and the overly click-bait bits.

Then on the other hand there are a relatively large number of reasonably good individuals who have dedicated their lives - sometimes at considerable risk - to keeping watch on what happens in society: the journalists. Within the best of the media companies these are free to operate without interference from the commercial - and sometimes political - part of the machine. The more the walls between those two break down and the more editorial control the commercial part has over the journalists the worse a publication will be.

You can see this mechanism at work in great detail in those publications that have a clear mandate imposed upon them from above, less so in better run organizations. None are entirely free from it but the range is quite wide.