News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Sunday October 06, 2019 @03:05PM (#21174208)
Regulated or deregulated — central bank fiat money created via debt instruments is inevitably self-destructive.

We are in a situation where essentially all global personal tax revenue goes directly or indirectly to pay commercial and central banks for the money supply to exist.

Destroy that — or be destroyed by it.

Everything else is just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by RealityVoid on Sunday October 06, 2019 @03:28PM (#21174421)
All money is essentially debt. It might be a failure of imagination from my part, but I can't see what you would replace it with except a system just like eit but not quite it.
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by rjf72 on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:30PM (#21174901)
He's referring to something in specific that many people do not consider. Most of our money is not printed, but created by fractional reserve systems through debt. Banks in general are only required to hold 10% of their deposits on hand. The rest can be lent/invested. If there's a run on the bank they rely on a central bank to give them money to cover it. Most people know this stuff, but consider this:

- Bob deposits $100 of 'real' money at a bank.

- Joe takes out a loan of $90 and uses it to buy something from Jane.

- Jane deposits $90 at the bank.

- Mike takes out a loan of $81 ...

And this process recurses on downward with a smaller and smaller share each time. But the mathematical result of this is that $100 of "real" deposits ends up creating $1000 of debt. And that's before interest which, for long term loans, can be multiplicative. So $100 of "real" money may end up creating thousands of dollars of debt. We've created a system where banks end up, quite rapidly, being owed literally more money than exists. Great time to be a banker for sure.

This is why the Fed and other financial entities are so obsessed with inflation. Inflation makes everything more expensive in the present, but it also reduces the cost of loans from the past. Imagine I take out a loan for $1000 and somehow the next day we see 100% inflation. Well now my loan can be paid back with only $500 of 'value' as measured from the time I took out the loan. If inflation is higher than the interest rate on my loan, I actually earn money by not repaying it. By contrast, deflation makes older loans more expensive. And of course there is also the investment outlook. Inflation is a penalty on wealth. If there's 2% inflation per year, my billion dollar piggy bank becomes worth ~$20 million less each year. So I'm incentivized to invest actively. By contrast with deflation I can sit on my money and become relatively richer by the day.

But this also puts us on a roller coaster. Old debt is only paid off with new debt which will only be paid off with new debt which ... And the money definitely does trickle downward, but at the same time it gushes upward. And the ride keeps going faster, and growing bigger. Not hard to imagine a different system as ours is grossly counter intuitive. Of course different doesn't mean better so, as a recurring theme in human history, we're only like to change once things go boom.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by crdoconnor on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:44PM (#21174989)
The flip side of money being created by creating loans is that it is extinguished when those loans are paid back.

Taxes also effectively perform the same function - destroying money (consider what would happen if all current tax money were burned and all government spending were printed - economically no different).

This side of the equation doesn't get a commensurate level of attention.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Sunday October 06, 2019 @06:03PM (#21175474)
All except the interest component, of course...

That requires the creation of additional money, borrowed into existence by someone else and then earned by the interest payer, in a never ending exponential cycle.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by princeb on Sunday October 06, 2019 @08:54PM (#21176350)
ideally, the loan is directed towards productive activity- the sowing of seeds purchased today for a harvest tomorrow, the construction of a factory today for gadgets tomorrow, the stocking of a store today for sales tomorrow, a home loan today for a person getting a job at a new city tomorrow - that will generate utility in the future. then the wealth generated from the interest is also wealth generated from new economic activity that never existed until the loan enabled it.

credit is only problematic when the expected activity fails to come to fruition, which is why the credit shrinkage acutely accompanied the economic shrinkage in the last crisis.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Sunday October 06, 2019 @09:25PM (#21176505)
All those observations are true, and there isn’t anything wrong with borrowing money and paying interest.

It’s the creation of money and paying interest that’s problematic.

This interest demands new money to be brought into being to pay it — to someone doing nothing but seeking rents due a monopoly position bestowed by the government; the banks.

This stream of interest payments is going out of the economy to whomever owns the commercial bank, but must be paid by people within the economy, who must borrow more money into existence to pay it — from the very people to whom it is “owed” (for no reason at all; they bear no risk, and provided no capital of their own).

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by princeb on Monday October 07, 2019 @08:16AM (#21179870)
> they bear no risk

how does the existence of loan defaults jive with the idea that loans have no risk?

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Monday October 07, 2019 @04:37PM (#21185694)
Banks leverage themselves 50-to-1, and then take huge volumes loans to unqualified clients, in the (historically accurate) assumption that the tax payer will be obliged to bail them out.

If the money creation aspect of banking was separated from the capital accumulation and loan-making/risk-taking aspect, things should unfold much differently. Particularly since there would be "fractional reserve" concept underpinning the money supply.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by captn3m0 on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:40PM (#21174974)
Thanks a lot. Can you recommend a book if I’d like to read more on this explained similarly.
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by chimi on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:07AM (#21177330)
This is one of the first things you'll learn studying Macroeconomics. Any introductory book on that topic will teach you about the concept.

In general, you can look for information pertaining to "How banks create money," which refers to your $100 deposit turning into $1000 after it completes the ownership ladder.

If you're still in college and have the opportunity to take some electives, I highly recommend Micro and Macroecon.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by maneesh on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:52AM (#21180760)
A great book on the creation of the fed and fractional reserve is The Creature From Jekyll Island
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by captn3m0 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:04AM (#21232121)
I almost bought this, but the author looks very shady:

>G. Edward Griffin (born November 7, 1931) is an American author, filmmaker, and conspiracy theorist. Griffin's writings promote a number of views and conspiracy theories regarding various of his political, defense and health care interests. In his book World Without Cancer, he argues that cancer is a nutritional deficiency that can be cured by consuming amygdalin, a view regarded as quackery by the medical community.[2][3][4] He is the author of The Creature from Jekyll Island (1994), which promotes false theories about the motives behind the creation of the Federal Reserve System.[2][5] He is an HIV/AIDS denialist, supports the 9/11 Truth movement, and supports a specific John F. Kennedy assassination conspiracy theory.[2] He also believes that the biblical Noah's Ark is located at the Durupınar site in Turkey.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._Edward_Griffin

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday October 06, 2019 @09:58PM (#21176666)
Fractional reserve banking does not exist, and did not for a long time. The real situation is even worse.

https://www.forexlive.com/centralbank/!/fractional-reserve-b...

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by Jommi on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:58AM (#21179411)
Well, you just linked a forum post on a forex trading website, I'm not sure how much weight I would put on that.

However, I did read the link and did some own research. I do see the argument that we need to revisit the causality of bank loans through the demand side argument. This however does not need to mean that "Fractional reserve banking does not exist". I'm not sure what makes you think that.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by ClumsyPilot on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:53PM (#21184580)
Apologies, this is indeed a shitty link. The commonly held belief that banks require a deposit before they can hand out loans is a myth, the financial system has not worked that way for at least 40 years, if ever at all. A bank's ability to create new money is enormous, and proper explanation can be found in this paper by the Bank of England: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by Jommi on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @09:18AM (#21202870)
So in a sense we agree right?
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Sunday October 06, 2019 @07:47PM (#21176044)
That's a great question!

When you create money through "taking a loan" against property, the bank creates deposits equal to the "loan", secured by your assets. These assets are attached by the bank (a lein), valued by an appraiser and insured against loss (at your expense).

The bank creates these deposits ex nihilo; the only one in this equation that has any wealth is you, and the bank is at little to no risk.

Imagine, instead, a scenario where all of this takes place; you have wealth, you insure it against all perils (loss due to destruction or theft, including title insurance against fraud, etc.), at your expense. You get it appraised, and then money springs into being. Exactly like today. Except with no bank, and no "interest" being charged.

The same limiting function is used, as by the banks; the amount of money allowed to be brought into existence for a certain amount of wealth is some percentage (say, for example, 75%, or whatever).

Except, this factor is dynamic; it is adjusted automatically as inflation or deflation occurs, dynamically issuing and withdrawing "credit" (the amount of money credited to your account due to the pledged wealth).

The value of the units of currency can thus be established at an absolutely fixed valuation (say, relative to a basket of widely traded commodities; steel, kWh electricity, pork bellies, OJ, barrels of WTI crude, etc.).

If someone needs to "borrow", in excess of the money they have created based on their wealth, they can do so on the private market; not based on some fanciful central-bank controlled interest rate, but at market rates from others with excess wealth/credit, at their own individual risk-adjusted market rate.

Anyway, that's a quick summary of one potential alternative.

Same highly dynamic money supply, most of the same "moving parts", but no central-bank interest stream is required to create the stock and flow of credit underlying the economy.

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by mistrial9 on Sunday October 06, 2019 @03:13PM (#21174285)
fantastic polemic -- utterly false dichotomy. We are in an age of massive systems, and systems-thinking is called for..
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by pjkundert on Sunday October 06, 2019 @03:22PM (#21174369)
The limiting function for money creation is the amount of wealth available to absorb it (both stock and flow).

Presently, that is secondary; the limiting function is the ability of civilization to maintain the interest payments to those private institutions mandated to create the money supply.

One of these concepts is necessary; the other is not.

Creation of dynamic money supplies based on the one limiting function is possible, and there are emerging mechanisms becoming available to support such money at scale — and make it available to the other ~4 billion people entirely unserved by the present system.

Care to comment on why this conversation is a “polemic”, and such a future is unimaginable?

Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by notacoward on Sunday October 06, 2019 @09:09PM (#21176429)
And what does "systems thinking" oh-so-conveniently mean this time?
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by maneesh on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:55AM (#21180789)
One thing that might be worth considering is where the best leverage point in the system is. See http://donellameadows.org/archives/leverage-points-places-to...
Re:High finance is wrecking the economy and the planet, but ... by millstone on Sunday October 06, 2019 @03:47PM (#21174590)
If an investor (say, a pension fund) holds treasuries, then this has the effect of redistributing money from taxpayers (via interest payments) to pensioners (via treasury yields). Where does the destruction come in?