Re:An Update to Our Community and an Apology
by simo7 on Sunday October 06, 2019 @04:48AM
(#21170686)
> Think of special pronouns as names.
That's exactly the problem: pronouns are not names for a reason.
Pronouns are meant to be a finite set of words that can group an infinite set of other words, names.
In many languages gender is the criteria to form those groups. It 's a natural choice if you think of gender as a binary category.
Once you introduce the concept of gender fluidity the most logical solution is to introduce a residual pronoun that includes everybody who doesn't fit in the male/female dichotomy.
To adopt instead a inifinite set of pronouns means to poorly re-engineer a language. It's an extremely important and complex common good, we shouldn't be tinkering with it so lightheartedly.
That's exactly the problem: pronouns are not names for a reason.
Pronouns are meant to be a finite set of words that can group an infinite set of other words, names.
In many languages gender is the criteria to form those groups. It 's a natural choice if you think of gender as a binary category.
Once you introduce the concept of gender fluidity the most logical solution is to introduce a residual pronoun that includes everybody who doesn't fit in the male/female dichotomy.
To adopt instead a inifinite set of pronouns means to poorly re-engineer a language. It's an extremely important and complex common good, we shouldn't be tinkering with it so lightheartedly.