News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dog learns over 1,000 words by electromagnetic on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @07:11AM (#2115487)
That's fair to say. Any comprehension is understanding even if it is just rote learning of single words to commands.

You're right, just because the dog doesn't understand 50+ words for 'drink' (water, coke, pepsi, coffee, tea, etc etc.) doesn't mean it isn't understanding in the same comprehension as if you got a 3 year old to bring you a 'drink'.

I don't know what I was thinking, I must have been in a state of sleep deprived idiocy. The simple fact you can teach a dog in human linguistics to sit when you say 'sit' signifies its understanding. You wouldn't get this response in an animal that all its communication skills are genetically encoded.

I remember reading about how Native Americans used to hunt Wolves with pitfall traps and how wolves would teach their young how to avoid the traps, like they would hunt a deer, they can also do the same with poisoned meats. These clearly show wolves are capable of understanding abstract concepts. Unless sink holes are a natural predator of wolves I doubt there's a genetic cue for "you see that flat piece of ground, you'll fall through that into a big pit" or "you see that steak, that's poisoned, but the one sat on the side of that metal contraption in their yard isn't!"

I was thinking of understanding along the lines that we can understand multiple meanings and abstract ideas. However, 1:1 learning is still understanding, and clearly Canis Lupis is capable of learning abstract ideas so a dog certainly has the ability to (even if we have to rebreed it into the species).

Re:Dog learns over 1,000 words by gnaritas on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @04:39PM (#2117530)
What's funny, is you're the guy with the dog; I have no pets. You should have been the one convincing me that your dog understands. Anyway, and up-vote for you.