Re:Nick Szabo: "The Singularity" is an incoherent and religi...
by wladimir on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @03:39AM
(#2115123)
Indeed. Belief that strong AI is never possible is also religious. If the human mind is simply a chemical computer (and, science currently says it is), it can (eventually) be simulated with sufficiently powerful hardware.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Nick Szabo: "The Singularity" is an incoherent and religi...
by borism on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @07:11AM
(#2115488)
I haven't yet heard any critic of Singularity religion claim that strong AI is never possible.
What we are skeptical of is that we need just a little bit of development and strong AI will take-off just like that without any regard to physical world constraints.
Re:Nick Szabo: "The Singularity" is an incoherent and religi...
by wladimir on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @07:39AM
(#2115552)
Well, one critic I usually hear about singlularity subjects is that "you can't upload your mind into a computer because the emotional/soul/bla aspects of a human being could never be emulated"... which is obviously religious. Yes, it's very very hard but certainly no reason to call it impossible.