News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dave Winer: "Twitter is a ghost town" by SwellJoe on Saturday June 07, 2008 @05:04AM (#211475)
So, the interesting thing, to me, is that a few weeks ago everyone was discussing the axing of Blaine Cook from the Twitter team for his "failure to scale". Turns out, nobody else in the company can scale Twitter or keep it online reliably, either. Huh. Must be a hard problem. It's probably a good time for folks to apologize to Blaine for piling all the blame on one guy for a problem that, in reality, took the whole development team to create and will take the whole development team to solve. (And it's time for everyone to stop pretending scaling can be solved by one magic bullet or another...if you don't build, or rebuild, to scale, you won't scale.)
[deleted]
Re:Dave Winer: "Twitter is a ghost town" by SwellJoe on Saturday June 07, 2008 @05:15AM (#211478)
OK. I trust you've built the scalable replacement for Twitter already and were just waiting for the opportune moment to launch? Now's the time!
Re:Dave Winer: "Twitter is a ghost town" by axod on Saturday June 07, 2008 @06:21AM (#211490)
Would you not agree that Twitter is a subset of the functionalities found in existing technology that does scale? email, IM networks, blogs...

Obviously you're entitled to your opinion about sending messages being a very hard problem, but I think it's been solved a few times now.

Re:Dave Winer: "Twitter is a ghost town" by notauser on Saturday June 07, 2008 @07:19AM (#211498)
All of those systems apart from IM follow the same route to success - a large number of independent systems with a common interchange format that makes it possible to create the illusion of integration.

Every mail server, every news server, every blog is a little island that runs on it's own. I would bet that behind the scenes even the big IM networks are actually a mountain of small, effectively independent, service providing systems that understand how to talk to each other - that's certainly how the XMPP/gTalk network functions.

This is only possible because all of those designs are fundamentally highly parallel - if your communication method has data dependencies (real or the result of bad design) that cannot be managed in that way then you get something that won't scale.

Re:Dave Winer: "Twitter is a ghost town" by SwellJoe on Saturday June 07, 2008 @04:16PM (#211686)
your opinion about sending messages being a very hard problem

I said scaling Twitter must be a hard problem, and that it will involve correcting their implementation rather than any one magic bullet. I said nothing about IM, email, blogs, etc.

You've decided that I'm talking about something that I am not.