Re:Show HN: My first game, minimal procgen gravity golf insp...
by spatulagames on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:50AM
(#21137055)
Thanks for the detailed feedback - some really good points.
Ghost arrow is something I thought of, but I was concerned it would make the game too easy.
Reset: you can long press without dragging to reset. There's a tutorial-prompt for it, but it only comes up when you appear to be stuck in a gravity well (which can happen).
Escape velocity: I did have this initially, but playtesters found it very frustrating and preferred to see a crazy figure-of-16 through lots of planets. I understand your point of view though.
That's very good feedback on hard mode - I wonder what I can change to make that more obviously a button. I personally prefer hard mode too.
Some ideas that would have made it even more fun for me, though which might change the game too much from your original vision:
Ghost arrow: show what shot I played last time, so I can tweak my strategy.
Reset: some sort of gesture to quickly go back to the start, so I can tweak based on the ghost arrow.
Escape velocity: a fun part of orbital mechanics, and a way to penalize me for just using a “hit as hard as I can” strategy where the only changes I make are shot direction.
Hard mode was the most fun because getting a cool hole-in-one felt really fun. I almost missed that hard mode was even an option — the help screen says “hard mode” so I assumed that was the mode I was in, but it turns out it was the button to play in hard mode, which turned out to be a lot more fun because of the reset mechanic.