News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Smell Difference Between Humans & Robots - Annoyin... by pornel on Monday January 17, 2011 @08:38AM (#2112076)
I notice that most people implementing CAPTCHA don't even fully realize what they're protecting from.

There are different kinds of spam, each needs a different approach:

1. targetted attack against a site

2. non-targetted attack sending spam for machines

3. non-targetted attack sending spam for humans

To protect against first case (e.g. someone trying to mass-register webmail accounts) you have to have a proper CAPTCHA, and JavaScript tricks and hidden fields are totally useless.

Most sites are only spammed with second type of spam, but choose protection against the first type! However, this spam is super-easy to defeat with content classification, because it has to make spammy keywords/links available to machines.

The third one is common in e-mail, rare on websites, but still can be mostly defeated with blacklists, classification and technical tricks that catch poorly written bots.

There are people implementing protection against #1, and then trying to prove it works, because it blocks #2 and #3. In non-targetted attacks, anything that wasn't expected by the bot writer will work, even if it's totally misimplemented CAPTCHA that has solution in image's URL, or it's a choose-a-kitten test that has 1 in 9 chance of guessing, or mouse movement tracking that can be trivially simulated/replayed.

There are no comments on this comment yet.