News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by dragontamer on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:28AM (#21116368)
I'm no financial expert, but based on discussions with them years back, it seems like Black-Scholes has all sorts of issues and isn't actually used in practice anyway.

Black-Scholes is basically the textbook model taught in schools. But modern finance has more complex models to address its flaws. In particular, Black-Scholes assumes that Call-options and Put-options are symmetrical, but in reality, people value put-options more than call-options. (In laymans terms: protecting against market drops is more valuable than protecting against market upswings).

Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by omeze on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:49AM (#21116656)
People ~5 years ago were certainly using Black Scholes where I worked, just with a lot of caveats. The volatility smile you describe only really applies to out-of-the-money puts - people trading with black scholes as a signal will look at the at-the-money strikes.
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by beezle on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:36PM (#21119432)
At the end of the day, excepting edge cases, the spread on most listed equity options absorbs any difference between model pricing.
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by bra-ket on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:45PM (#21117230)
it is used everywhere as the foundation, all the more recent models (stochastic vol/Heston, Local volatility, SABR, SLV, SVI etc) are just incremental extensions and generalization of Black-Scholes
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by dragontamer on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:39PM (#21117786)
At its core, Black Scholes is a set of "obvious" differential equations.

You assume a normal curve. You define "volatility" (the market's uncertainty to the price of something) as Geometric Brownian motion with some standard-deviation / variance, and then perform differential equations on that to determine the "proper price" of an option.

After all: Options grow more valuable in times of uncertainty, and grow less valuable when everyone can accurately predict future prices.

The part that "brakes" because of negative rates is the "risk free rate", predicting the future value of money. To me, it seems like there are a variety of obvious extensions you can do to fix this problem. You could redefine Black-Scholes to operate on "Real" terms, and then convert everything back into "normal" terms later.

----------

Black Scholes doesn't "fundamentally" require postivie interest rates for the risk-free rate. It was just an assumption that they had in the original model. But as a differential equation, its pretty easy to tweak your assumptions around and fix these issues.

But any such tweak means you're no longer working with classic Textbook Black Scholes. Sure, it served as the basis of the theory, but you gotta account for more real-world variables than the original textbook model.

Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by Xcelerate on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @12:23AM (#21122049)
> At its core, Black Scholes is a set of "obvious" differential equations.

Interestingly, the Schrodinger equation works about the same way. Just assume a handful of reasonable and "obvious" things about physics, and out pops the equation.

Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by mcguire on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:37PM (#21119438)
Isn't Black-Scholes based on a normal distribution? Is that an appropriate probability distribution?
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by ryeights on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:32AM (#21116417)
Additionally, Black-Scholes does not account for the possibility of early exercise in American options (versus European options, which it was designed for)
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by dragontamer on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:35PM (#21120667)
More like Black-Scholes fails to account for dividends, which is the only reason why you'd want to exercise early.

Under normal circumstances, a call option is always more valuable than the stock itself. The exception is of course, the dividend. True owners of the stock will receive the dividend, but call option holders will NOT.

However, for any stock without a dividend (ex: AMD, Tesla, etc. etc.) American vs European style doesn't seem to matter. Its always better to hold onto the option of buying a stock, rather than being "forced" to buy the stock.

Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by rabidrat on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @01:44PM (#21128320)
> Its always better to hold onto the option of buying a stock

Tax laws change that equation significantly.

Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance by cm2187 on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:59PM (#21117993)
It is used for quoting between market participants. People may use more complex models for the underlying pricing and risking, but they will quote option prices in black/black-scholes format as an implied vol.