Re:The Social Network Wins Golden Globe for Best Picture
by twidlit on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:13AM
(#2111293)
The Social network was good and all but Inception was a masterful, intelligent film that was original to boot. Far better IMHO.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Social Network Wins Golden Globe for Best Picture
by hugh3 on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:39AM
(#2111332)
As it happens, I saw both of these films for the first time in the last week or so.
I'd say that Inception was a hugely ambitious film which didn't quite hit its mark, while The Social Network was a much simpler, much less ambitious film which just happened to be nearly flawless. Inception was a fifteen-course lobster meal where a couple of the courses were a little salty, while The Social Network was just a dish of masterfully-prepared spaghetti, far better than spaghetti has any right to be. Which of these you think is more worthy of recognition is a bit of a broader question.
Re:The Social Network Wins Golden Globe for Best Picture
by twidlit on Monday January 17, 2011 @07:34AM
(#2111977)
I'd say the one pushing the envelope while achieving some mass market success... but that's just me, cuz i happen to want more ambitious films.
Re:The Social Network Wins Golden Globe for Best Picture
by icandoitbetter on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:37AM
(#2111330)
No, Inception had a mediocre direction, atrocious dialogue, wooden characters, overcomplicated-without-being-deep plot. Not that I take the Golden Globes seriously, but I'm certain that Inception did not deserve the award.
Re:The Social Network Wins Golden Globe for Best Picture
by anto1ne on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:40AM
(#2111340)
And Black Swan was a masterpiece too, way better than The Social Network IMO.
IMDB seems to agree that Inception > Black Swan > TSN which makes me wonder who are the judges of golden globes ?