News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by feanaro on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:35AM (#21106669)
What is your theory though? Who is pushing this concept and for what gain?
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by bborud on Sunday September 29, 2019 @09:14AM (#21106848)
> What is your theory though? Who is pushing this concept and for what gain?

"Who benefits" is always a valid question. However in the climate and energy debates it is usually just left hanging there - implying that some cabal of shady characters somehow benefit. The question serves very little purpose if it isn't followed by a somewhat coherent story that points to "who benefits" and "how".

So in order to redeem yourself, would you mind terribly answering who benefits. And perhaps why this is either good or bad? Names, numbers and observable facts.

As for who doesn't benefit, that's much easier: incumbent energy companies and the immense government interests in maintaining the status quo. (Even the tinfoil hat "free energy" quacks manage to harp on about who is thwarting their efforts to supply the world with free energy).

Heck: _I_ would benefit from maintaining the status quo. I live in Norway - a country whose pension fund is built on oil revenue and is currently the largest national sovereign wealth fund in the world. My quality of life as I retire is directly linked to how large this fund is. It would be in my interest that we keep pumping out hydrocarbons for as long as possible so we can load up on stocks and not depend on being innovative or doing actual work to remain wealthy.

(That being said, this pension fund is essentially a giant index fund. So there's that :-))

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by feanaro on Sunday September 29, 2019 @04:26PM (#21109416)
> So in order to redeem yourself, would you mind terribly answering who benefits. And perhaps why this is either good or bad? Names, numbers and observable facts.

I might have misunderstood the comment I was replying to. I thought it was ironically suggesting that "climate catastrophe" is being pushed by some due to an agenda so I was genuinely asking who this was and what the agenda is.

At least it's my suspicion I might have misunderstood something since I'm a bit confused by the replies to my comment.

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by bborud on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:14PM (#21130731)
Ah yes, sorry. I misunderstood who I should really be responding to :-)
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by aalleavitch on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:39AM (#21106681)
Who has more to lose here and who has more resources to put towards propaganda and disinformation, climate scientists and green energy companies, or a deeply entrenched $1.7 trillion/year fossil fuel industry?
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by tekmate on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:42AM (#21106696)
sure, you could arrive at this rhetorical question after about 30 seconds of rational thought OR you could be a contrarian and feel super smart because you saw through a conspiracy!
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:49AM (#21106736)
The better question is how much money can by made now by getting in on the hype as early as possible. Just look at the disclosures.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by aalleavitch on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:55AM (#21106757)
You don’t run an effective propaganda campaign on resources you don’t have yet. The comparison in existing entrenched oil wealth to the money behind climate activism is absurd.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:12AM (#21107134)
Obviously not true, a propaganda machine based on ideology runs itself, all the better if there is money to be made.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by javajosh on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:48AM (#21106724)
Wikipedia has some good content about this. Basically in the 80's petrol funded think tanks pushed the idea that global warming was an phenomena created from whole cloth by a cabal of globalist leftists. I'm not sure of the exact claim of what they were/are trying to achieve, but essentially they want to put the brakes on capitalism by making people consume less, and ultimately disrupting economic growth.

There are a few reasons why this was effective, especially in the US. The first is the most powerful, best expressed by the old Upton Sinclair quote, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." Second, many believe that God would never do such a thing to us - it states clearly in the Bible that the world is ours to do with what we want, and it would be unjust for God to let us shoot ourselves in the foot like that, and God is not unjust. And third, it's not even real science, just dirty red communists trying to psych us out, and feckless scientists out for grant money. Fourth, Americans seem very prone to believe on authority, powerful and wealthy people, even when the statement is self-serving.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming has a lot of great content, and is well linked to, e.g., climate change denial articles.

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Sunday September 29, 2019 @01:49PM (#21108469)
> I'm not sure of the exact claim of what they were/are trying to achieve, but essentially they want to put the brakes on capitalism by making people consume less, and ultimately disrupting economic growth.

That cabal definitely exists, it's the old "Malthusian vs. Cornucopian" debate, revived in the form of the Club of Rome and people like Paul R. Ehrlich. Lots of scientists have this attitude. The scientists that do not have this attitude are rarely heard, because anything less than the impending apocalypse barely sells an newspapers.

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by solarengineer on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:43AM (#21106702)
What about all the data? What about direct evidence like the glaciers melting way, and the coral reefs dying? There is video evidence of these two, fyi.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by The_rationalist on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:35AM (#21106668)
What is the likeliness of global warming being a climate catastrophe?
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by bborud on Sunday September 29, 2019 @09:23AM (#21106897)
It is actually quite high. The problem is that we won't really know until it is too late. For instance, if the growth of phytoplankton collapses, it might well mean that really large ecosystems collapse in relatively short order.

And it isn't really as simple as "well, I don't eat fish anyway". It is unlikely that other ecosystems wouldn't be affected by this. There is a greater than zero probability that if this happened today you would be dead in a few years. If not of starvation then due to societal collapses resulting from a sudden shortage of resources.

The thing is, the things that can result from climate change are not part of our experience so we can't really relate to it. We're used to "tomorrow is going to be more or less like today" and "well, this has never happened before so it can't happen".

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:15AM (#21107152)
It is quite high but you don’t know. Okay.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by bborud on Monday September 30, 2019 @09:21PM (#21121149)
How much time would you be willing to invest in understanding a longer answer? I suspect not much so why should I waste my time?
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:16AM (#21125539)
If you know better, why didn't you write a better answer in the first place? What's there to "understand", why does it need to be long? Just list the bad things that you know are likely to happen.

Don't do it for me, do it for yourself and posterity. As it stands, your answer is only fit for preaching to the choir.

Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by bborud on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:13PM (#21130720)
What would be a better answer to you? No, seriously, what would convince you?
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by hanniabu on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:55AM (#21106759)
I think you mean an environmental catastrophe, which I would say 100% since we're pretty much there already with some key glaciers breaking away, the many species going extinct, and the collapse of coral reefs and plankton.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by gridlockd on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:17AM (#21107158)
If we are there already then frankly I am cool with it.
Re:Nuclear Fusion Could Rescue the Planet from Climate Catas... by fallingfrog on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:41AM (#21106691)
Likelihood is probably the wrong way to look at this, since it completely depends on human behavior. That’s like asking, what’s the likelihood of my eating a banana. It’s whatever likelihood you want it to be.