News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by CDSlice on Saturday September 28, 2019 @05:07PM (#21102876)
I am not sure what makes this a paradox? Normally I think of a paradox as leading to a state where you have two or more contradictory statements being true at like Russell's Paradox in set theory. This just seems like a problem where you don't have enough information to solve it but once you get the info you need (how to pick random chords) you get a logically consistent solution.
Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by malisper on Saturday September 28, 2019 @05:39PM (#21103052)
A paradox is any statement that appears to contradict itself. That includes both actual contradictions such as Russel's paradox and statements that appear to be invalid, but have non-obvious valid conclusions like the Monty Hall problem.

This problems falls into the second category. We are given what appears to be a well-defined problem, but when we solve it in different ways, we get different answers. The resolution to the paradox is the problem isn't well defined because your technique for generating randomness will produce different answers.

Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by OscarCunningham on Saturday September 28, 2019 @08:13PM (#21104014)
Because of the Principle of Explosion, a contradiction implies any statement. So for people who don't think that everything is meaningless there can't be any true contradictions. This means that in fact every paradox falls into the second class. Paradoxes merely differ in how difficult it is to see the logical flaw that leads to the apparent contradiction.
Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by lonelappde on Saturday September 28, 2019 @06:50PM (#21103546)
It's a paradox because esteemed mathematicians, including authors of classic books, have vociferously argued that their particular arbitrary choice is the sole correct choice.

In probability, one must make many unstated assumptions to get an answer to a problem. Usually one believes those assumptions are "canonical", like uniform independent distributions. Sometimes woldviews contradict each other.

Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by krick on Saturday September 28, 2019 @09:20PM (#21104344)
Yeah. I'm ok with calling anything that looks weird a "paradox" (even stuff like "The Monty Hall problem"), but in this case describing the problem this way is precisely what's misleading about it: the person describing the "problem" must first pretend that there is a well defined (even though possibly not known to the less educated listener than himself) "random" way to pick 2 points on a circle, which there clearly isn't: there are different algorithms to do that, that produce different distribution, which very obviously look different when plotted, and choosing any specific algorithm/distribution makes the "paradox" disappear. So I really dislike when stuff like that is called a "paradox". It's just a way to trick the listener (or yourself) into thinking there is a problem, when there really isn't any.
Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by vageli on Sunday September 29, 2019 @02:40PM (#21108821)
> Yeah. I'm ok with calling anything that looks weird a "paradox" (even stuff like "The Monty Hall problem"), but in this case describing the problem this way is precisely what's misleading about it: the person describing the "problem" must first pretend that there is a well defined (even though possibly not known to the less educated listener than himself) "random" way to pick 2 points on a circle, which there clearly isn't: there are different algorithms to do that, that produce different distribution, which very obviously look different when plotted, and choosing any specific algorithm/distribution makes the "paradox" disappear. So I really dislike when stuff like that is called a "paradox". It's just a way to trick the listener (or yourself) into thinking there is a problem, when there really isn't any.

It is also a good way to broach a discussion on the nature of randomness.

Re:Buffon's needle or how ants estimate nest size by rolleTx on Saturday September 28, 2019 @07:06PM (#21103646)
Exactly, this is just a definition problem