This is a good principle, but it assumes that inequality is due to the fact that people who work more earn more, which most proponents of egalitarianism argue isn't the case in today's society.
It doesn't assume that, it prescribes that.
> ... which most proponents of egalitarianism argue isn't the case in today's society.
Since most people get paid by the hour, those who work more (paid) hours do earn more. Of course not all work is equally valuable or productive, nor is all compensation commensurate to those factors.
Still, even if in our system more work didn't translate into more compensation, that has no bearing on whether it should.
If by egalitarianism you argue "equal pay for equal work", then that implies both unequal pay for unequal work, as well as income inequality for those who work less over those who work more.
If we reduce inequality down to a single number, we cannot asses whether that inequality implies unfairness. We can achieve perfect equality by giving everyone exactly the same amount of money - no matter what work they perform, or whether they perform any work at all. That would obviously be unfair.
The goal was never to pay people the same amount; in fact, such a scheme wasn't even proposed by Karl Marx himself (he argued against the idea that we should all be "paid equally") - I should have actually stated the other case, in which people who don't work more (all factors relating to productivity considered) actually end up earning more than those who do.
I'm of the opinion that the sort of equality which most people seek cannot be found in a system of wage labour and capital - precisely because of them.
For the decades following WWII, Americans didn’t have to compete with much of the world. Those economies were closed off and burdened by counterproductive rules and restrictions. American workers had the leverage to extract more income.
But once those countries opened up, Americans had more competitors. Most Americans still sit comfortably in the GLOBAL 1%, but now many more people around the world have the income to do things like buy medicine, have sanitary and safe living conditions, go to school, and even retire. More people are living longer, healthier lives and fewer are having to bury their children.
Economic systems are very very complicated, and trying to explain them in a way that humans will even begin to wrap their minds around requires assumptions and simplifications. But it’s better to have a profession that is iteratively improving our understanding of human behavior and incentives than leaving it to our evidently flawed instincts and intuitions that has led us down the path to human suffering more times than not.
I don't, because the predominant measure for inequality is the GINI, which has exactly those flaws that I am pointing out.
Furthermore, the GINI based on wealth is even more misleading, because it's mostly based on the paper wealth that people have accumulated. Economic stimulus policy that inflates asset prices is responsible for that rise. Just look at the GINI vs the S&P500 [1] and you'll find that suddenly in 2008 people became "more equal". They weren't better off for it though.
[1] https://research.stlouisfed.org/publications/economic-synops...
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-economic-ineq...
This is a natural competition mechanism. It's not at all specific to modern economic systems. Pretty much all animals arrange themselves in a "pecking order". It's particularly pronounced in sexual selection.
However, let's say I work less than you and therefore I earn less. This is fair, I can rationalize it, but it's still a numeric inequality and it shows up in a statistic as such.
Therefore, you can just say "inequality does X", it's too simplistic. That's my whole point.