News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Review My Startup: Skinnyo - Weight loss challeng... by Mz on Sunday January 16, 2011 @09:17AM (#2109368)
RE: "sustainable growth"

Consider what features you might need in order to keep current members as long term members. The problem with the focus on weight loss is that people will fall into one of two categories: 1) Yo-yo dieters who will keep coming back to lose the weight again or 2) People who make real changes to their lives, lose the weight and keep it off. Your current configuration most likely has long term appeal only for group one. In the long run, this could smack of failure in terms of the big picture: Do you really want to be known as the site that actively encourages people to regain the weight/be yo-yo dieters so they can come back (and line your pockets some more)?

Think on what "challenges" you can introduce to keep the actual successful people around and contributing members of the community. This might be stuff like "has kept it off for x period of time and counting". They could get kudos of some sort and held up as good examples for the rest of the community. It could differentiate into fitness challenges -- run that 5K, move on to a marathon (or whatever).

Re:Ask HN: Review My Startup: Skinnyo - Weight loss challeng... by space-monkey on Sunday January 16, 2011 @09:10PM (#2110953)
I agree with Mz that the most likely long term users aren't necessarily success stories. I think it's reasonable to expect that you're going to have significant churn.

When someone stops using the site regularly after achieving their goal, though, they are still very valuable to you. Find a way to follow up with those folks each 6 or 12 months and you can hopefully gather data to prove that your model works. The people that have been the most successful may very well want to talk about it.

Being able to say "5000 people have used Skinnyo to meet their weight goals and kept the weight off for 12 months" in big letters on the front page could help your conversion rate, and may even help current members stick with it.