News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by cannonedhamster on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:47AM (#21091909)
No one is saying tear down everything he had ever done. All that's been said is that someone with a history of being aggressive, supporting of paedophilia, unable to determine appropriate times to debate, and lacking social graces wasn't the best person to lead an organization. RMS has had a long history of getting a pass for his actions because of his skill and passion, he was excused for behaviors that would get most people fired. Humans tend to act like this, a long buildup of frustration followed by quick action once a boiling point is reached. Look at most civil wars for instance. I think RMS made the right decision by stepping back and not letting the outrage fall onto the organizations he's part of. As is abundantly clear from the comments here, RMS will never lack for support regardless of what he does, so I don't think anyone needs to be concerned about him landing on his feet, he's going to be absolutely fine.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:29AM (#21093028)
> All that's been said is that someone with a history of being aggressive, supporting of paedophilia, unable to determine appropriate times to debate, and lacking social graces wasn't the best person to lead an organization.

That doesn't sound like what happened at all.

More like he dared to challenge a witchhunt against someone with a tenuous connection to Epstein, and the witchhunt turned on him.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bdcravens on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:19PM (#21094718)
RMS has long been a controversial person, with a very abrasive personality. I think even had he been an angel he would have received the same result in today's cancel culture, but there's a lot of people who have looking to turn on him and just needed an excuse. Most people won't come to a bully's defense.
[dead]
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:49AM (#21093256)
Is there any evidence Minsky was a pedophile? What I heard is that Minsky once attended an Epstein party where an underage woman came on to him (at Epstein's behest) and he refused. And Stallman's comments were about that, not defending Epstein.

But now you say "Stallman came out to defend the pedophiles", so you must have some evidence I haven't heard.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by merlincorey on Friday September 27, 2019 @01:43PM (#21094365)
> But now you say "Stallman came out to defend the pedophiles", so you must have some evidence I haven't heard.

I believe people are referencing his long history of notes[0] supporting pedophelia such as this:

> 04 January 2013 (Pedophilia)

> There is little evidence to justify the widespread assumption that willing participation in pedophilia hurts children.

> Granted, children may not dare say no to an older relative, or may not realize they could say no; in that case, even if they do not overtly object, the relationship may still feel imposed to them. That's not willing participation, it's imposed participation, a different issue.

[0] https://stallman.org/archives/2012-nov-feb.html

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:17PM (#21094697)
You shouldn't post that without also posting this:

> Many years ago I posted that I could not see anything wrong about sex between an adult and a child, if the child accepted it.

> Through personal conversations in recent years, I've learned to understand how sex with a child can harm per psychologically. This changed my mind about the matter: I think adults should not do that. I am grateful for the conversations that enabled me to understand why.

https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#14_September...

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by DanBC on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:55PM (#21095689)
I don't get why people think this is some killer defence of Stallman.

Most of us realise that fucking children is wrong because it's harmful to those children. We don't need to be told this.

He talks authoritatively about stuff he has no idea about. That combination of arrogance, ignorance, and stunning lack of sensitivity is pretty hard to take from someone who is supposed to be using language as a tool of their job.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @04:04PM (#21095764)
> Most of us realise that fucking children is wrong because it's harmful to those children. We don't need to be told this.

Do you imagine you were born with that belief?

For most of human history, and in much of the world today, people believed otherwise, certainly about 17 year olds (the age in question here). It's not something people just know.

It's something people come to know either through careful thought (like Stallman) or simply because they accepted what they were told (the "most of us" you've described).

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by DanBC on Saturday September 28, 2019 @02:52AM (#21098873)
I was not born with those beliefs. Did Stallman make those comments (that the harms of incestual abuse can be avoided if condoms are used; that "willing" child abuse shouldn't be a crime) when he was a new-born child, or when he was a fully grown adult?

The point is that these comments have no relevance to his work; he doesn't know what he's talking about but doesn't realise his ignorance; he has no ability to empathise with other people; yet he makes those comments anyway.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by merlincorey on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:26PM (#21095445)
That's great and I agree anyone who is not pro-pedophilia should surely be heartened by Stallman's change of view here, however, I will point out that this entry is from 2019 September 14.

That means these personal conversations and change of heart have come after the recent MIT mailing list posting and subsequent fallout.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:50PM (#21095654)
It only means that he didn't publicly say so until this incident.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by 9935c101ab17a66 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @02:09AM (#21105411)
If that is the case — and I say that with a healthy dose of skepticism — don't you think that alone is problematic?
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by _coveredInBees on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:34AM (#21093076)
Have you actually read all the statements he posted publicly on his site? Because your comment glosses over almost everything he said, and how he said it, to make it seem as though he were some completely innocent, blameless party caught up in a shitstorm because he dared to voice a countering opinion.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:38AM (#21093114)
You can't ignore the timing.

If he wasn't fired/forced to resign because of his comments about Minsky, why did it happen just after those comments?

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by dmurdoch on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:44AM (#21093198)
Because those comments brought him to the attention of people who were not as familiar with his work. They then saw many comments about pedophilia and his behaviour towards women in the industry.

His comments about Minksy aren't enough to warrant the backlash. But his LONG history of poor behaviour absolutely is. He brought the spotlight ON HIMSELF by commenting on such a high profile case. That spotlight then listed all his flaws. Those flaws got him where he is today.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by leereeves on Friday September 27, 2019 @12:13PM (#21093514)
That's not what I saw. Instead I saw (and still see) people (in this very thread even) saying he "came out to defend the pedophiles". Media stories discussing his remarks about Minsky, with headlines vaguely connecting him to Epstein. The famous Selam G. hit piece mostly about (and misreading) his comments about Minksy. His past remarks and behavior are at most a footnote in these stories.

That said, I agree it's clear he made a lot of enemies with his past behavior and that certainly didn't help him at a time like this when he needs allies willing to stand against the mob and speak on his behalf.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by soulofmischief on Friday September 27, 2019 @01:43PM (#21094374)
Supporting pedophilia? How in the ever loving Christ did you come to that conclusion?
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by cannonedhamster on Saturday September 28, 2019 @03:20PM (#21102306)
You should really look it up. He posted multiple prior blog posts on his website about it. There's a link someone provided further down in the chain. It surprised me as well when I learned of it, but he injected himself into that debate willingly and deliberately.