News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by Barrin92 on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:25AM (#21091092)
communities only stay in control through active intervention by some strong enough authority. This is the problem with the 'law of the jungle' logic of crypto currency, not having any authority doesn't imply that the system doesn't move towards centralisation, it simply builds out informal hierarchies, and those are usually a lot worse than formal and legitimised ones because they are based on resource concentration and have nothing to reign them in. Well functioning markets are constructed and reconstructed through social interaction and institutions, they don't predate them. That they simply exist in harmony and tend towards some magical happy state is essentially religious thinking.

The Tyranny of Structurelessness (https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm) is a great and pretty timeless piece on why decentralisation does not lead to some sort of greater freedom or community control.

Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by jkepler on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:32AM (#21091162)
Could that one not have rules without rulers, if the protocol and incentives are properly structured?
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by pjc50 on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:39AM (#21091232)
Only if you never, ever upgrade the software. As soon as you need to make changes, that unavoidably hands control to those doing the changes.

(This has become very apparent among all the bitcoin forks; the "default" fork has won every time because hardly anyone can be bothered to pick a specific one and it's far better to be on the majority one)

Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by jkepler on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:38AM (#21091789)
Except that there have been multiple upgrades on the original Bitcoin chain. The software is on version 0.18. While preserving backwards compatibility, today bitcoin includes Segregated Witness, which separated the constraints on unspent transaction outputs from spending transactions (this also solved the transaction maleability problem). That upgrade alone showed us that changes the majority of network participants accept can be upgraded, but even when a strong consortium of powerful merchants or mining groups tried to force change, no one group could---though folks argued and tried to change it for more than two years. There are multiple stakeholder groups who have to form consensus for upgrades: protocol developers, application devs, network security folks(i.e. miners), full-node users validating transactions, merchants accepting payments, and users choosing wallet software; thus, upgrades are hard but possible when really necessary.

Network forks simply show that the entire system is voluntary and non-coersive: if you disagree, you're free to built an alternative with like-minded people. But if the economic activity doesn't follow you, you're left with a not much more than a free software project.

Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by garmaine on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:05AM (#21092121)
Nit, but the key point is that it preserves forwards compatibility.
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by me_me_me on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:10AM (#21091529)
Exactly, and you can see the extremes people with go to, in order for them to control and enforce their views ie Bitcoin cash.
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by jkepler on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:41AM (#21091832)
But the Bitcoin Cash devs can't force anyone to use their fork. Users are still free to run the software or not.
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by me_me_me on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:04AM (#21092117)
Yes, but it shows that people will do a lok of shady things in attempt to capture the reins of control. At the moment you have rather educated in crypto people using crypto. You don't have to think hard as to what happens when majority of people have their say on things they have no idea about (appeal to emotion /emotional manipulation).
Re:Telegram quietly snuck its blockchain past regulators by glitchc on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:28AM (#21091702)
Rein; not reign.