Re:Be wary of functions which take several parameters of the...
by gnud on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:34AM
(#21089400)
c# already has the 'chained' API in the standard library:
On the other hand, it also has the more error-prone
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Be wary of functions which take several parameters of the...
by Lio on Friday September 27, 2019 @04:06AM
(#21089557)
I know nothing about C# so please pardon my ignorance but how does:
new FileInfo(srcPath).CopyTo(dstPath);
provide more protection vs CopyFile(src: srcPath, dest: dstPath);
Assuming that both path strings are set correctly isn't a typo here going to cause the same error and be just as visible?e.g.
new FileInfo(pathA).CopyTo(pathB);
CopyFile(src: pathB, dest: pathA);
neither would seem to show which is correct without knowing what the path values are if the variable names are ambiguous.
Re:Be wary of functions which take several parameters of the...
by gnud on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:03AM
(#21090533)
When using the FileInfo api, it's obvious which argument is the source and which argument is the destination. When using the CopyFile, it's not.
If you can't keep track of your variable names, then using keyword arguments, like others here talk about, won't help much, either.
Re:Be wary of functions which take several parameters of the...
by Lio on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:21AM
(#21090637)
Sorry, not sure if your parent was edited to remove keynamed parameters from the second example or if I've responded to the wrong comment.
I'd definitely agree with you that the not having named arguments is worse than your method chained example.
To me named parameters seem to be on a par with the chained OO api.
Re:Be wary of functions which take several parameters of the...
by gnud on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:27AM
(#21091112)
Ah, the reason is simple: C# allows named parameters, but do not enforce them. You can call File.Copy both as
File.Copy(a,b)
and File.Copy(sourceFileName: a, destFileName: b)
And confusingly, also as File.Copy(destFileName: b, sourceFileName: a)