Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by panny on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:19AM
(#21092269)
Are you doing anything to help copyleft licensed code repos find infringers? We all know it's common practice for unscrupulous developers and companies to take copyleft code, copy it, and then try to relicensed under permissive licenses on a regular basis. Like Google did with Oracle's GPLed Java source code.
It seems irresponsible for Github to continue distributing infringing code when it clearly has the tools to prevent that happening. Youtube has fingerprinting for infringing music and video. Github should be doing the same with source code.
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by efdee on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:19AM
(#21092916)
> Like Google did with Oracle's GPLed Java source code.
That's not what happened -at all-.
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by bpt3 on Friday September 27, 2019 @11:11AM
(#21092818)
How does Github clearly have the tools to prevent copyright infringement from happening?
If you're saying they are the entity in the best position to identify infringement, I would agree, but what tools does Github already have in place to do that?
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by panny on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:46PM
(#21097270)
Github can ID project dependencies and notify devs when one of them is vulnerable to a CVE. They could more easily find licenses for all project dependencies also, they just don't. Github could id private repos using GPL code for non-gpl licensed projects. Github could even automatically apply the correct GPL license and make the projects public, which would satisfy the license.
By failing to do so, Github really seems to be encouraging copyright infringement.
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by bpt3 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @12:59PM
(#21127711)
Nothing you described here is a trivial problem, nor a problem that Github has any responsibility to unilaterally fix, nor do they have the tools to do so already as you previously stated.
If Github were somehow helping copyright infringers, that would be encouragement. What you're describing is additional effort on their part to actively discourage copyright infringement, which is not the same thing.
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by desiderantes on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:51AM
(#21092610)
>Like Google did with Oracle's GPLed Java source code.
What are you talking about?
Re:GitHub releases an ImageNet for code and a CodeSearchNet ...
by glennpratt on Saturday September 28, 2019 @02:58PM
(#21102185)
Test files that were not shipped to customers...
We used the repo-level license information from github to filter to free non-copyleft licenses, and the license files are actually stored next to the extracted data corpus (see https://github.com/github/CodeSearchNet#Licenses).