News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by nieksand on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:40AM (#21089098)
Can you provide an actual link for [2]? It's a very serious allegation.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by ccalf on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:51AM (#21089158)
There is none; the people who keep promulgating this falsehood about Stallman say that because of one paragraph that anyone who can pass the SAT reading comprehension tests, parse standard English, or understand the basics of logical reasoning, would have understood that it is simply a wrong interpretation at the level of how 1+1 = 3 is wrong.

It is much better to accuse Stallman in that instance that he was mansplaining and contributing to workplace toxicity, and/or to accuse Stallman of a historical pattern of objectifying women. Those are better because they are closer to the truth. But people like simpler narratives, that he said this one horrible thing, when it is not even that far fetched to show using the exact same quote that he was actually arguing quite an opposite, or orthogonal, point.

The other thing about this is that people ignore the context of the speaker; in this case Stallman was talking about media abuse of terminology. To complain about media manipulation is a very standard, leftist position. So like the above, to implicitly suggest that he was using this position as a cover for his personal misogyny, has merit, but nobody cares about this angle, because again it's too complicated to sort through.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by adamsea on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:14AM (#21089284)
So simple that it requires so many words to explain ;)
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by ccalf on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:24AM (#21089336)
Actually, the SAT reading comprehension questions are not that simple and trip people up. Which is really my point of analogy. They're the kind of questions where you either got the right answer or not, but explaining it to the person who got it wrong can be non trivial.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by abdullahkhalids on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:36AM (#21089411)
Almost an opposite of NP problems. Easy to solve, but hard to convince someone else that your solution is correct.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by josefx on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:38AM (#21089425)
I think this part of his emails could be constructed as that

> We know that Giuffre was being coerced into sex -- by Epstein. She was being harmed. But the details do affect whether, and to what extent, Minsky was responsible for that.

Stallmans defense of Minsky is reasoning that he could have been an unknowing participant who wasn't aware of the lack of consent.

His opinion on the age of consent is another matter:

> Does it really? I think it is morally absurd to define "rape" in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17.

Source: https://pastebin.com/658yfLj5

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by denton-scratch on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:29AM (#21090687)
It's worth noting (again) that the age of consent at that time, in that place, was 16.

I believe RMS is on record saying that he thinks the idea of a legal "age of consent" is a nonsense. It's entirely an arguable position that if two 16-year-olds have sex together, they have not necessarily raped one-another. He's saying that it's not the age that makes it rape, and that therefore the law is an ass. The law effectively defines consent as something that cannot legally be given by someone younger than X. Obviously the younger someone is, the less likely it is that they can give consent; RMS is complaining that the law gives X an arbitrary value.

One can disagree with him, either with a proper argument, or simply by denouncing him; but it's not morally reprehensible for him to reason in that way.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:36AM (#21090727)
> It's worth noting (again) that the age of consent at that time, in that place, was 16.

This is not a point I particularly care about, but it's worth pointing out that you are wrong, so far as I can tell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ages_of_consent_in_North_Ameri...

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by denton-scratch on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:12AM (#21090982)
I don't care much about it either, but thanks for the link. It seems there's a close-in-age exemption that wouldn't have applied in the Minsky case anyway.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by DanBC on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:31AM (#21090698)
> It's worth noting (again) that the age of consent at that time, in that place, was 16.

Even for American's travelling to that country? Even for prostitution?

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:52AM (#21089502)
This is not the most damning part of the email to me. I excerpted the part I thought most relevant here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21089394
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by NhanH on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:49AM (#21089148)
He didn't said that. But at this point, I think everyone made up their mind about the reading of the email. Here is the original email thread you can read and decide for yourself https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6405929-091320191420...
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:45AM (#21089122)
Yes. This article[1], so far as I can tell, contains the full nuance of the story. He claimed (or very strongly insinuated) that if a minor sex trafficking victim presented herself as "entirely willing", then a man who had sex with her is not guilty of sexual assault. I believe that's what I said in my comment.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/09/17/computer...

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by smsm42 on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:55AM (#21089180)
He did not claim that and did not insinuate that. It's like saying that person that doesn't believe we should use term "piracy" to describe copying software without obtaining license, because piracy implies violent robbery, thinks that violating copyright is OK. It's a total non-sequitur and failure of reading comprehension to the point of functional illiteracy.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by zajio1am on Friday September 27, 2019 @06:47AM (#21090438)
Which is AFAIK true in my jurisdiction. While he could be prosecuted for child abuse (if the victim is minor), but not for sexual assault or rape, as that requires mens rea, which is not here if the victim presented herself as 'entirely willing'.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:00AM (#21090522)
Maybe. In many US states it's a strict liability crime.

But you'll notice that nothing about my point hinges on whether RMS was right or wrong. My claim was about what RMS said (which you seem to grant), not about whether he was correct in saying it.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by zajio1am on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:52AM (#21090840)
If i remember correctly, Stallman made semantic argument, not legal argument.

There are at least three levels of analysis - semantic (which are proper words describing the act), descriptive legal (whether the commited act is crime) and normative legal (whether the commited act should be crime).

Note that the law does not prescribe language (if the law defines some crime named XYZ mean it overrides common language meaning of XYZ). It is the other way - criminal law defines which classes of acts are crimes and then uses common language names for them (which may or may not fits perfectly).

Stallman first made semantic algument about 'sexual assault' and later later did semantic or perhaps normative legal argument about rape definition.

(With second reading, the rape definition comment was also clearly semantic.)

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @08:42AM (#21091258)
> If i remember correctly, Stallman made semantic argument, not legal argument.

I agree! Stallman's claim was (at least mostly) semantic. Specifically, it hinges on the claim that sexual assault means something that involves coercion on the part of the assaulter. He adds to this a factual argument that (assuming Minsky did have sex with her), he was probably unaware of the fact that she did not consent. Therefore (he concludes), Minsky probably did not commit sexual assault.

But ... you'll notice that this is exactly what I've been saying throughout this thread. RMS is defending Minsky against the charge of sexual assault by saying that she probably pretended to consent (which means he probably didn't physically force her to have sex).

Maybe you want to defend this claim. I'm not here to argue for or against it. The simple statement that I made in the OP was that this is what Stallman said, and the rest of the thread has basically been trolls claiming he didn't say it with no evidence.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by zajio1am on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:49AM (#21091941)
You are using phrases 'commit sexual assault' and 'guilty of sexual assault', which in my reading implicates legal level of analysis. Stallman does not use these phrases, and plain reading of his mail clearly expresses semantic argument.

Therefore, your original post could be read as misinterpretation of Stallman semantic argument as legal argument.

Also your original claim "While I believe that what he said[2] is so far beyond the pale of responsible discourse that removing him from his positions" would IMHO make more sense when your post is read as Stallman making (wrong) legal argument.

Everyone is entitled about per opinion on proper usage of language so it does not make sense why a semantic argument in general or this one in particular would be 'far beyond the pale', considering that his semantic argument makes (IMHO) perfect sense.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by bscphil on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:18AM (#21092257)
Surely any charitable reading of my comment would have to assume that I'm responding on the same frequency as Stallman? After all, RMS himself just says

> The word “assaulting” presumes that he applied force or violence, in some unspecified way, but the article itself says no such thing.

He doesn't spell it out for you that he's speaking about the semantics of "assault". In quoting / responding to Stallman, there's no reason I should have to either. I could (uncharitably) assume RMS meant the legal definition of assault too!

I don't think most of the people who have a problem with what Stallman said misunderstood him. I also don't think you're entitled to just use words however you want; semantics isn't the same thing as defining words for yourself.

Even if you really try to force that position, at best you end up with the view that Stallman thinks someone might be misled into thinking Minsky did something worse than he actually did, where what he actually did was have sex with an underage sex trafficking victim, and what you were misled into thinking he did was physically force an underage sex trafficking victim to have sex with him. He thinks the claims against Minsky are "inflated".

But ... if the former is what Minsky did, that's a really fucked up thing to do. It's assault, as the majority of people seem to understand it. Trying to diminish the nature of the assault by saying that she appeared to consent comes across at best, even under the kindest interpretation, as a really weird point to make. It's incorrect to say that you can't assault someone if they appear to consent. That's what people are upset about.

As I've said elsewhere in the thread, I'm not particularly interested in defending the wrongness of RMS's statement. (I made that point in my OP, actually.) What I'm trying to defend (and rather bemused by the responses to) is the claim that he actually said these things.

Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by pseudalopex on Friday September 27, 2019 @06:59AM (#21090510)
It is not true where the alleged act took place.
[dead]
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by F-0X on Friday September 27, 2019 @03:22AM (#21089324)
That's not what was said _at all_. You simply have not read the post correctly, and worse, your phrasing exaggerates the actual situation.
Re:Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project by SamReidHughes on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:38PM (#21094933)
So what are you saying? He agrees with Stallman? That’s even worse!