Re:Gigantic Chinese telescope opens to astronomers worldwide
by esyir on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:00PM
(#21087723)
For public safety, those that function well don't matter that much if the overall trend skews heavily negative though.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Gigantic Chinese telescope opens to astronomers worldwide
by tempguy9999 on Friday September 27, 2019 @07:17AM
(#21090618)
This is what it's like arguing with many anti-drugs person. Whatever you say, they'll counter it with anything to push their 'prohibitive' agenda.
It's not even that there's no room for compromise, there's no space even to discuss it, to try and understand their rationale. It's like being a kid again in a classroom with the teacher shouting at you that you can't do that and no they won't explain why.
Re:Gigantic Chinese telescope opens to astronomers worldwide
by homonculus1 on Friday September 27, 2019 @10:31AM
(#21092397)
The scary part is that drugs were only volunteered as an offhand example. Authoritarians (in this case openly) apply the same logic to literally any activity, such that even the most vague and indirect tertiary externalities can be twisted into an excuse to police other people. Even the most responsible engagement in [drug use]/[sex]/[motorcycle riding]/[controversial art]/[self-defense]/[political protest] is subject to their judgment and approval because your example might influence someone else!
But even though this loose standard can be stretched to justify literally any prohibition, in practice the only activities that get targeted in the name of community enhancement are the ones that make the group in power feel threatened or uncomfortable.
Re:Gigantic Chinese telescope opens to astronomers worldwide
by robocat on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:34AM
(#21089068)
Maybe we need drinking licences. You need to pass multiple tests that cost a lot of money to administer, and if you are caught breaking the rules you get a fine or go to jail (depending on the legal framework, which rules you broke, and how good your lawyer is).