E: And even if it was, and was capable of “shifting” left or right, which is a nonsensical notion about populations, a shift of a few IQ points wouldn’t have a dramatic many-fold increase in perfect scores.
But it's a moot point because an increase of 2 points among people in the 99th percentile implies little about those in the 99.99 percenteth quantile.
Some description of a fat tail from 60-99 percentile doesn't say much about the top one percent. At a certain point, the dating market tops out.
> (Also, intelligence/aptitude/performance scales like IQ, SAT, or ASVAB scores are arbitrarily numbered, so I'm don't know what a "fat tail" means in that respect. Maybe there's a standard definition that isn't completely arbitrary.)
Er, you can look at plenty of cardinal-scaled things like vocabulary or digit span. Doesn't change the non-normality at the tails.
https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2008/07/20/why-heights-are-no...
It's close to a normal distribution one or even two deviations away from the mean, but real-life has way more samples appearing +5 deviations away from the mean. I haven't really looked into it ever, but this could be because of a positive skew versus a distribution with purely fat tails?
(Also, intelligence/aptitude/performance scales like IQ, SAT, or ASVAB scores are arbitrarily numbered, so I'm don't know what a "fat tail" means in that respect. Maybe there's a standard definition that isn't completely arbitrary.)
Personally, I don't buy it. The Flynn effect is large enough, and the way the normal distribution works with tail effects, that if there were any Flynn effect in general (much less focused on the high end), that you should see dramatic effects like several-fold increases in the number of perfect SAT scores. You don't see anything remotely like that - even despite loads of countervailing factors like increases in SAT access and prep!