News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by Athtar on Saturday January 15, 2011 @07:32PM (#2108227)
>H.264 is an open standard. It was developed by a committee, standardized, reviewed by many engineers and developers for multiple companies and has been standardized for use with a multitude of containers and devices.

>VP8 is not a standard. It was developed secretly by a single company, and until recently, had only a single working implementation. The public wasn’t open to collaboration on the specification until the bitstream spec was frozen, including the bugs that existed within.

This is an interesting point. One I had never even realized.

Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by kenjackson on Saturday January 15, 2011 @08:29PM (#2108321)
This is an important point not just for ideological reasons, but it is one reason why the FUD argument is not symmetric.

Since H264 was implemented in the open with open and large membership to the body, it is more difficult for some company to come out of the woodwork and say, "Hey, we have a patent that H264 rides on, but we didn't know it until now" Note, QCOM tried this with H264 several years ago and got their butt handed to them by the courts (http://www.broadcom.com/press/release.php?id=1037466). People have had 10 years to examine this open specification. I think its reasonable to say that one would have found a violation by now. And almost all the majors are already either licensees or licensors. There's a slim chance that there's a patent floating around in some patent troll portfolio that hasn't been examined, but that's the only real vector I can see of a legitimate surprise H264 patent violation.

Whereas with WebM its been in the public domain less than a year. It could feasibly take a few years for it to be reaonable that anyone who would have done due diligence to have done so. It's completely reasonable that in a year from now Siemans comes out and says, "WebM infringes these three patents we have". A court is not likely to throw it out saying they've been sitting on them.

Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 16, 2011 @02:03AM (#2108898)
I don't think Qualcomm would even have lost that case if not for their participation in the standardization process. MPEG-LA is probably under no obligation to disclose the extent to which they believe their portfolio is infringed on by WebM until it becomes profitable to do so, so we will likely not know whether this is the case until WebM achieves significant uptake, if that ever happens.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by etherealG on Sunday January 16, 2011 @11:21AM (#2109572)
While what you're saying is true, the royalties side of things has been locked down by Google's legal team very effectively. If said patent holder makes a patent claim against WebM they automatically destroy all free royalty rights for themselves on the same codec (if I understand correctly). This means that while they could try to hold Google (or any other user of the codec) to some kind of patent royalties, Google could retaliate for any use that company or individual makes of the same codec (with as much leeway to set a price as the patent gives the original individual or company.

This is the true genious of the WebM license. It means even if this does happen in the future, Google can destroy whoever has this patent through a massive counter. It also means that any challenge would have to be made extremely carefully.

edited for spelling :)

Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by cornedpig on Sunday January 16, 2011 @11:34PM (#2111211)
Doesn't matter if the patent holder is a troll with no viable products of its own.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by yuhong on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:30AM (#2111322)
But H.264 would not be immune to that either.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by bad_user on Sunday January 16, 2011 @09:57AM (#2109416)
Since when are patents thrown out because the company/patent troll is sitting on them? Patents are not trademarks and you don't have to actively defend them.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by mikeryan on Saturday January 15, 2011 @08:25PM (#2108314)
There's almost very little point to opening up the VP8 standards process. It seems pretty much designed to challenge H.264 but avoid its patents (how well? TBD). Its severely bound in what it can be by trying to avoid H.264's existing patents.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by pyre on Saturday January 15, 2011 @08:39PM (#2108340)

  > Its severely bound in what it can be by trying to avoid
  > H.264's existing patents.
Doesn't that describe anything that isn't h.264? Might as well say that h.264 got there and patented everything good, so they must have won. We should just pack up and go home, they get to have a monopoly on video codecs for the next 14+ years.
Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by mikeryan on Saturday January 15, 2011 @08:46PM (#2108352)
Doesn't that describe anything that isn't h.264

Yeah probably - ask the Theora guys how hard its been ;-) The upside is that it could very much, out of necessity, drive some considerable advancement in video compression algorithms.

Re:The Ambiguity of Open and H.264 vs. VP8 by gorog on Sunday January 16, 2011 @08:57AM (#2109338)
We already have wavelet codecs like Dirac, which are quite exotic compared to MPEG4 / VP8 / Theora.