Re:At Tech’s Leading Edge, Worry About a Concentration of Power
by orbifold on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:38AM
(#21081266)
While I agree that 10^17 seems like a more accurate number, don’t forget that each neuron contains ~10^5 synapses which all process at timescales of 10s of microseconds. This gives you an additional factor of 10^9
Re:At Tech’s Leading Edge, Worry About a Concentration of Power
by Veedrac on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:59AM
(#21081481)
The 10¹⁷ includes that factor. 10¹⁰ neurons by 10⁵ synapses by 10² Hz. It seems unlikely to me that the meaningful temporal resolution is going to be 1000x that of the firing rate, but if you want to add a factor of 10 or so I wouldn't object.
Bostrom's estimate of 10¹⁷ is much, much more reasonable.
Note that this is still a number biased in favour of the brain, since for the brain you are measuring each internal operation in an almost fixed-function circuit, and for Summit you are measuring freeform semantic operations that result from billions of internal transitions. A similar fixed-function measure of a single large modern CPU gives about 10¹⁷ ops/s as well; the major difference is that a single large modern CPU is running a much smaller amount of hardware many times faster, and uses binary rather than analogue operations.