News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by colechristensen on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:39AM (#21078221)
> I've explained what I see and what I think many people see when they talk about 'processed foods' in a way that makes a fuzzy but usefully coherent classification.

No you haven't and you won't because their isn't one.

You made hand-wavhing non-explanations that revolved around ambiguous feelings about the person making the food that you couldn't possibly turn into a system to classify food as processed or not processed.

I asked many many questions about what your definition of processing was or if it applied in specific scenarios and you wouldn't or couldn't answer.

It's past the point where I'm interested in continuing, I don't see anything coming of this.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by jodrellblank on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:25PM (#21084525)
You asked a lot of obviously trap styled bad-faith questions to try and force a clear edge boundary which I already said I cannot provide.

I also cannot provide a clear boundary between 'delicious' and 'disgusting', and those are also hand wavy and ambiguous and guided by risible feelings, but there is still merit and usefulness in describing them.

I, too, can ask tons of careful trick questions about "if I take a delicious cookie, then put a drop of pig blood in it, but you don't know it's there, does it THEN become a disgusting cookie? What if it was three drops and a snail but they were boiled and minced first? AH GOTCHA you can't draw a clear precise measurable line between delicious and disgusting, so there can't be a difference".

It's past the point where I'm interested in continuing, I don't see anything coming of this."

If it was true that you were past the point of continuing, you wouldn't have continued. Guess you do understand the idea of a fuzzy boundary after all.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by zbentley on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:34AM (#21091756)
And yet distinctions made based on the average of feelings about a bunch of related things are used every day, to great avail, and are absolutely critical to everyone--and I do mean everyone--'s decision-making ability and common sense.

Just because it cant be rendered into a perfect line in the sand or measurable, objectively-defined system of classification doesn't mean it's not useful.