Looking only at clinican costs is akin to saying that a sandwich should only cost $1.50 because that's the cost of the ingredients.
Doctor wages tie into personal health insurance, medical malpractice insurance costs, hospital system insurance costs, and more.
Even if you were correct on the cost bit (you aren't), you're completely ignoring that artificially constraining the SUPPLY of doctors causes massive cumulative ripple effects adding up to significant costs across the system.
The AMA is absolutely a cartel restricting supply and artificially keeping wages high. Have you taken a look at any other health care system in the world?
Your repeated use of the phrase "cartel" is not impressive or convincing to me. In every other field: civil engineers, lawyers, real estate agents, accountants, teachers, police, and countless others have licensure, education, and training requirements.
And thanks for you concern, but I am familiar with many other global heath systems.
I notice you ignore LNPs and PAs in your analysis.
NPs and PAs are not allowed to perform a significant number of medical procedures; I see you ignore that, conveniently, and bringing it up isn't much other than a red herring.
The "cartel" term has been used both colloquially and in academic literature for quite some time:
https://www.jstor.org/stable/2352286?seq=1#page_scan_tab_con...
Here are some other reading links.
http://www.jparksmd.com/blog/a-massively-overpaid-cartel
https://wallstreetpit.com/5769-medical-cartel-md-salaries-hi...
https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2017/06/04/milton-f...
https://fee.org/articles/the-medical-cartel-is-keeping-healt...
As a consequence of the overwhelmingly positive benefit of lifting the artificial supply of MD (or DO), doctor salaries will naturally drop, as necessitated by economics.
We also need to fix the high administrator-to-doctor ratio that adds costs.
Insurance companies provide little value and just extract money from people. They need to go away.
Many low-income people skip out on preventative visits because they can't afford them. This leads to high-cost illnesses later down the road that could have been prevented or mitigated with proper care.
So yes, doctor salaries are inflated, there is a shortage of doctors, and the AMA is a cartel that limits supply. But there's more to it than that.
Blue collar workers tend to wait, as you said, until an illness becomes critical - because they have to work 9-5, the same hours doctors work. With an additional 25 or 50% of MD workforce, we can easily begin offering preventative care services outside of 8-5, allowing low-income people to get the preventative care they deserve without affecting their livelihood.
We should strive for primary care visits to be available 7am-7pm (at least), 7 days a week, in every hospital/clinic in the nation. And specialist visits should be bookable in ~2-3 weeks max, not the 6+ week timeline many individuals requiring a specialist face.
I agree with all your points, and definitely the administration costs I hope will drop as we get better ML/AI technology. I don't personally see a realistic way to get rid of the insurance companies, but they can be quite harmful. Finally I also would like to double down that the "cartel" aspect is the single largest contributing factor.
That is the peril of this type of analysis. Clinician cost is only 20% of total healthcare spend. Your premise is flawed so your conclusion is invalid.