News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A patent lawsuit against GNOME by noonespecial on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:05PM (#21072755)
I think examiners (and non-technical folks who don't think much about it) get fooled by "pseudo-novelty". Progress moves fast in the technology field, especially with computing. Every year things that were impossible last year become possible through simple incremental improvements. If you're not paying attention the new uses might actually seem novel rather than just the obvious applications of the better machine.

Edit: Not sure why that's controversial... Some time around 2009 I finally got my parents hooked up with cable internet vs the DSL they had before and wowed them by playing a movie over the internet from my home media server. I didn't invent "a method and process for transmitting a full length movie over a network without quality degradation", but my mom sure thought so. I did some "computer work" and a "novel" new ability emerged.

Edit: Changed whats in () to something less offensive.

Re:A patent lawsuit against GNOME by bdowling on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:56PM (#21075363)
> examiners (and non-technical folks who don't think much about it)

Patent examiners all have degrees in science or engineering. See, for example, this job listing: https://www.usajobs.gov/GetJob/ViewDetails/545074300. They're also organized into art groups which become experts in narrow fields of inventions.

> simple incremental improvements.

Almost every patent issued is an incremental improvement of some other invention. By "simple" you probably mean non-obvious, which is one of the requirements for patentability.

> I did some "computer work" and a "novel" new ability emerged.

That's a different kind of novelty. It's not patentably novel if anyone, anywhere in the world, ever did it publicly before you.

Re:A patent lawsuit against GNOME by vonmoltke on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:59PM (#21073338)
> Edit: Not sure why that's controversial...

> (and normies in general)

I don't think it would be controversial had you not condescendingly referred to "normies".

Re:A patent lawsuit against GNOME by noonespecial on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:37PM (#21073784)
Ah. Thanks. Doesn't sound off to my ears but that makes sense. I'm going to try and soften that while I can. Thanks for taking the moment to answer.
Re:A patent lawsuit against GNOME by stordoff on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:57PM (#21077153)
FWIW, Wiktionary notes it as "usually derogatory", and to my ears it makes it sound like you are saying you are inherently better than them (which I'm sure is not your intention). A word best avoided in my opinion.