News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by brudgers on Saturday January 15, 2011 @09:47AM (#2107051)
Disclosure: My spouse teaches online for Phoenix.

Phoenix's success and also a source of criticism is due to its liberal admissions policy and therefore it accepts students who might not be considered fully prepared for college level courses by other institutions. People can legitimately come down on both sides of such an enrollment policy, on the one hand, it can be argued that it deprecates the value of a college diploma while on the other it can be argued that the enrollment policy provides access to capable people who would otherwise be denied.

With nearly half a million students and a liberal admissions policy, there are a lot of poor performing students. It is statistically inevitable. But I would suspect that the least prepared students are not much worse than those major US universities admit on athletic scholarship based on their meeting the NCAA's minimum qualifications. Like the major universities, financial gain is the reason Phoenix admits such students.

Like any school, a student's education is dependent on a number of factors. One thing Phoenix deserves credit for is the size of the classes and the emphasis on discussion. Even within mandatory freshman classes, class size is typically twenty students or less and meaningful participation in these discussions is 25-30% of the grade by university policy. Unlike many prestigious public universities, Phoenix doesn't create 200+ student classrooms and does not allow faculty to structure courses in a way which discourages open discussion. In terms of class structure, Phoenix is akin to a small liberal arts college, and that has real educational value.

Technologically, classroom communication uses is entirely disconnected - basically NNTP style newsgroups with a web front end available and most of Phoenix's classrooms are relatively low tech and emphasize reading and writing rather than streaming live video and chat. Importantly, this offers the financial advantage of reduced overhead for the University, and improves access for students with limited bandwidth.

As a publicly traded company, there is no doubt that Phoenix is in the business of selling degrees - but then again, the marketplace also plays a meaningful role in establishing the price of a Harvard degree, and the recent movement into online education by public universities is no less motivated by the bottom line.

While reduction in costs is one reason public universities are moving into online education, the real driver in many cases is increased fees. Online education offers public universities the opportunity to attract more student's from out of state which translates directly into higher tuition. But more tellingly, it is not uncommon for public universities to charge out of state rates to all online students regardless - including those who would qualify for in-state tuition rates on the bricks and mortar campus.

Because Phoenix's online faculty is largely adjunct, they can handle declines in enrollment more readily than their public university based competition, and because they don't try to compete based on cutting edge high bandwidth classrooms, their technology costs are relatively low. That's why they have been able to maintain revenues.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by danielford on Saturday January 15, 2011 @11:47AM (#2107221)
Open admissions and small courses can be found at a community college for a fraction of the price for-profits charge. My main concern about for-profits are reports from their adjuncts that they've been pressured to pass students who perform poorly. A lot of their students also lack basic reading and math skills because for-profits don't have the remediation requirements you would see at a community college.

I'm all for seeing what market forces can do to improve education. But I'm worried that a lot of these students are going into massive debt to get a degree that won't be valued in the marketplace, due to lack of academic standards.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by brudgers on Saturday January 15, 2011 @12:20PM (#2107303)
>"My main concern about for-profits are reports from their adjuncts that they've been pressured to pass students who perform poorly."

That is not the experience related by my spouse, and I would suspect that there is less pressure at Phoenix than at some large and well known institutions. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/14/sports/ncaafootball/14aubu...

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by jmm on Saturday January 15, 2011 @02:00PM (#2107525)
Why keep talking about college athletics? Comparing U of Phx admissions/passing criteria to that of high level athletes at big schools is not exactly redeeming. Because everyone knows the idea of the scholar-athlete at major programs is a mostly a farce (which is not to say there aren't exceptions).

Addition: And if you're simply trying to knock non-profit higher ed from a pedestal, my point is that it's already been knocked. At the same time, there's a continuum of relaxed academic standards and capitalizing on certain types of enrollment, so U of Phx is not necessarily on equal standing simply because there are some concerning things happening at Big Football U.

Did you catch the law school article which was the #1 article for several days on nytimes.com this week? My thought is that with all of this, the education bubble needs to deflate some lest it burst.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by ahi on Saturday January 15, 2011 @02:01PM (#2107530)
Auburn is a bit of an outlier. It is sometimes referred to as a football program with a university attached. Auburn has faced NCAA sanctions half a dozen times in the past 20 years. My friends teach at U of Michigan and report their football players as being comparable to the rest of student population, at least during the Spring semester.
Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by angstrom on Saturday January 15, 2011 @01:15PM (#2107423)
Has your spouse seen this video? If not please watch it. I would be curious if you could debunk/shed more light on some of the issues it raises: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/collegeinc/view/

My concern about for-profit education is that its interest is focused more on the investor and less on the student outcomes. Students are admitted fairly easily and loans from for-profit banks in addition to any federal funding create what looks like a ponzi scheme taking advantage of people's aspirations. Once the pool of gullible students are dried up the scheme busts and the tax payers are the ones holding the bag.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by ataggart on Saturday January 15, 2011 @02:43PM (#2107611)
>My concern about for-profit [services] is that its interest is focused more on the investor and less on the [customer].

Funny how elsewhere the profit motive aligns suppliers' actions to the demands of their extant and would-be customers, since to do otherwise would be to go out of business. Perhaps the issue here is that multiple levels of taxpayer subsidies yields a system of perverse incentives.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by forensic on Sunday January 16, 2011 @03:32AM (#2109015)
Why would a for-profit business not serve its customers?

Your criticism applies to public schools far more strongly than it does to private schools.

Public schools focus on pleasing their investor - the government - at the expense of their "customer" the student.

Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by bane on Saturday January 15, 2011 @09:52AM (#2107056)
Couldn't one say that poor performing students at UoP is a sign that the school's grading and student evaluation is fair (i.e. the system is working) as opposed to rampant grade inflation seen elsewhere?
Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by simplify on Saturday January 15, 2011 @01:10PM (#2107414)
I think this viewpoint can't be stressed enough. Evaluating schools based on what percentage of their students do well is a very slippery slope to encouraging schools to lower their standards to the lowest common denominator.
Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by brudgers on Saturday January 15, 2011 @10:09AM (#2107080)
My spouse teaches there, I don't really know what the grade distribution is. However, my understanding is that poor academic performance by Phoenix students is often a function of background and immediate circumstances.
Re:University of Phoenix Enrollment Down by 42% by forensic on Sunday January 16, 2011 @03:34AM (#2109019)
So.. poor performance is due to the same reasons that poor performance is usually do to.

Why is it wrong that Univ of Pheonix is giving these students a chance?