News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tape still beats SSDs and hard drives when it comes to pr... by adrian_b on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:08AM (#21068453)
I have been using in my home for several years a Quantum external LTO-7 drive, which is connected via a Serial-Atached-SCSI cable, so I also have a SAS HBA card in a computer. I am living in the European Union and I have bought the required hardware from an on-line shop from Germany, where it was cheaper. Now you can also buy it easily e.g. from Amazon. The cost was around 3000 EUR.

The tape cost is about 10 EUR per terabyte. Previously I was using HDDs for archiving. I have not followed closely the evolution of the HDD price, but looking now on Amazon I see about 30 EUR per terabyte.

I have a data archive of about 120 TB, but I am paranoid because of past data losses due to defective HDDs/CDs, so I store 3 copies of each tape (in different places).

That means that by using tape instead of HDDs, I have already saved 20 * 360 - 3000 = 4200 EUR.

Someone who would store just 2 copies of each tape (the minimum rational value), would need to have a data archive of at least 75 TB to recover the initial cost.

Nevertheless saving money is not everything, you also gain peace-of-mind because the chances of the tape becoming defective just from storing are negligible compared to a HDD, which if not used for a very long time might never start spinning again.

With tapes you must transfer the data only when you can no longer buy drives that would read them. With HDDs you should better replace them before their warranty expires, as I have seen too many that died immediately after that.

The tapes work OK both in Linux and in FreeBSD, but the FreeBSD utilities are more convenient, so I have connected the tape drive to a FreeBSD server and I transfer the data to be archived through 10 Gb/s Ethernet, which is faster than the 6 Gb/s SAS, so it is not a bottleneck. The writing speed of LTO-7 is 3 Gb/s, so that is the bottleneck anyway, not the interfaces.

That speed is much faster than of any HDD of up to 8 TB that I have ever used, but I have not checked the latest HDD models to see if they have improved their speed to levels comparable to tapes.

Using tape is very simple and retrieving any file (I have a tape index on my SSDs) takes at most 3 minutes, including the time to manually start the drive and inserting a tape in the drive. The maximum seek time is about 2 minutes. When I had a HDD archive, there was still the same time for manually selecting a HDD and inserting it in the HDD rack. For retrieving very large files, the tape can even be faster, due to the faster sequential speed.

The conclusion is that if you have data of at least several tens of terabytes and/or if you value that data enough to want to avoid any chance of losing it, than magnetic tape remains the best solution for now.

There are no comments on this comment yet.