News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tape still beats SSDs and hard drives when it comes to pr... by userbinator on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:27PM (#21066988)
It's not about compression, but total storage capacity.

Imagine a disk. It has two sides and a certain surface area, as well as a certain density (bits per square in/cm). A standard 3.5" HDD platter has a bit more than 4200mm^2 of surface area (having been unable to quickly find the dimensions of an HDD platter, I grabbed the dimensions of a floppy disk from the standard) per side, or a little less than 10000mm^2 per platter; I'm being deliberately rough with the numbers since all we need is an order of magnitude.

Imagine a tape. It's long and thin, and can be rolled up. An LTO-8 is 960m long and 12.65mm wide, for a total surface area of 12,144,000mm^2. Tape has a lower recording density than HDDs (LTO-8: ~20Kbit/mm * 6656 tracks, or ~128MB/mm^2 compared to ~1Tbit/in^2 = ~185MB/mm^2 for a HDD), but more than makes up for it with its length.

Re:Tape still beats SSDs and hard drives when it comes to pr... by sliken on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:07AM (#21067508)
That's all well and good, but tapes are smaller than disks. LTO-8 is 12TB and the 14TB disks have been out for a good while.

Also with inefficient tapes you end up spending many more tapes for inefficient incrementals, incredibly long seeks, and lack of efficient deduplication.

Then there's other nasty surprises like a relatively narrow temperature range for tapes and an improper alignment of the head can result in tapes you can read and write... but when the drive dies you can't read the tapes anywhere else.

Tapes still make sense above a certainly scale, but I think it's around 10PB before the real world costs of tapes, drives, robot, support agreements, extra capacity for inefficient incrementals/dedupe, etc.

The big win with tapes is it's much more feasible to rotate tapes offsite.

Re:Tape still beats SSDs and hard drives when it comes to pr... by adrian_b on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:24AM (#21070057)
> but tapes are smaller than disks

Tapes are also physically smaller, therfore their capacity per volume is better than for HDDs. Two LTO Ultrium catridges have about the same volume as a 3.5" HDDs, so you have 24 TB in the same space as a 14 TB HDD.

Moreover, the HDDs are much heavier. You can easily carry a suitcase with 20 tape cartridges, i.e. with 240 TB.

If you would carry a suitcase with 17 HDDs (238 TB), that would be around 14 kg (around 31 lbs). Possible but not at all comfortable.

Re:Tape still beats SSDs and hard drives when it comes to pr... by caf on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:38PM (#21067376)
After multiplying the single track linear density by the number of tracks, you also need to divide by the tape width to convert to a recording area density number. So you end up with about 10.9Mbit/mm².