As for Ising model, D-wave didn't outperform classical algorithm after classical algorithm was tuned (it was a new problem, so existing classical algorithm wasn't the best possible), see https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.1084, also there are reasons to suspect why Ising model will not provide any quantum speedup, see https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.5693.
To answer your question specifically: DWave does not allow the same level of control over qubits.
Quantum supremacy in any reasonable sense of the word supremacy is a long way off.
1. https://hal.inria.fr/file/index/docid/451604/filename/smalli...
> [quantum computing supremacy] term refers to the use of a quantum computer to solve some well-defined set of problems that would take orders of magnitude longer to solve with any currently known algorithms running on existing classical computers
.. and continues to explain why this setup does exactly that.
But comparing it to manned flight or the first nuclear reactor... In those two cases there was a clear path to something very useful. I’m my mind this experiment changes very little as to how probable it is that we will soon have useful quantum computers, or even that we will ever have them. I guess that’s another question for Scott’s list:
Q: If what we care about is computing solutions to difficult real world problems, in what way is this a meaningful milestone?
The first flight was 2 people in a plane that lasted very short. I could have ridden my horse more quickly over that distance! How is this a meaningful milestone?!
Well.. it demonstrates something that cannot be done on a horse (classical computer) but that can be done with a plane (quantum computer).
Is the application useful today? Probably not. But that shouldn't discourage anyone.
Not a lot of people directly own & operate their own airplane, let alone a nuclear reactor, and yet both have had a significant impact on modern life. As for this experiment & QC, only time will tell of course.
I completely agree with this statement. This is mainly about Extended Church-Turing Thesis.
That is still clearly quantum supremacy, even if Shor's algorithm is not yet implementable.
Q: Why can the D-wave not be used to illustrate “quantum supremacy” in a similar way?
(As I understand it the D-wave can sample from the solutions to ”ising model-like” problems, which I assume would be extremely difficult for a classical computer to do (but probably possible to verify).)