Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by ghaff on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:39AM
(#21049920)
Even in the US I’ve had pushback from lawyers about external links from websites and other official content. The idea is that it’s something of a tacit endorsement.
Yes it’s being conservative but the lawyers definitely prefer fewer links where possible and I’ve had them ask me to remove quite a few.
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by a_c on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:35AM
(#21049266)
I am very curious to know if the rule of "being responsible to the link a website links to" applies transitively, i.e. a link in the link my website link to. If applies, then can the law be interpreted as my website needs to be responsible to the entire internet. On the flip side, if the rule only applies to one layer deep, then a url shortener would defeat the whole law
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by gmueckl on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:40AM
(#21049325)
The rule applies to the content you end up seeing after your browser follows all automatic redirects and possibly even interstitials (ads/disclaimers). Redirects are an irrelevant technical detail in this context.
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by irrational on Monday September 23, 2019 @09:50AM
(#21048903)
Are they expected to continually monitor the linked website? What happens if they add the link and then a week later something "bad" is added to some sub-page of the linked website?
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by gmueckl on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:54AM
(#21049440)
A quick search seems to indicate that yes, you might be responsible for linking to the altered content. As a website author you have - in principle - a duty to check what you are linking to. It is unclear what that means in practice. I would guess that it would involve a test if timely detection of alteres content on the linked site would have imposed an undue burden. The only part that is absolutely certain is that a website owner must react if they are notified that they are linking to illegal content. Other than that, it's seemingly a grey area.
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:38AM
(#21049292)
So how many times have each of the search engines been sued?
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by gmueckl on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:44AM
(#21049364)
Guess why the remaining search engines are so good at classifying certain types of sites of the "adult entertainment" and and other such types?
I am not sure if the courts distinguish between automatically generated pages and authored/curated content that involves human input in its creation. Courts haven't been exactly consistent on these points.
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by heeen2 on Monday September 23, 2019 @03:30PM
(#21052645)
Plenty of times. Have you ever seen a notice from Google referencing chillingeffects.org at the end of your search results?
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by C1sc0cat on Monday September 23, 2019 @12:05PM
(#21050174)
Has ever happened and does this also cover newspapers?
Re:Thomas Cook collapses, stranding 150k UK holidaymakers
by gmueckl on Monday September 23, 2019 @01:25PM
(#21051121)
Yes, I remember a high profile German tech news site involved in at least one such legal battle. If memory serves, it revolved around a link to Alcohol 120%, a tool to rip copy protected disks. The news site lost the case, I think.
So while involving lawyers every time is definitely high on the CYA scale, it may make sense to run some instances by a lawyer to be safe(er). The subsidiary's website shouldn't generally be much of a problem, though.