The Cubes failure was almost entirely down to its price tag. Had it been cheaper I have no doubt it would have been a massive success. I, and everybody I know, really wanted one, but non of us could justify the massive price tag. The mini on the other hand was launched both the cheapest mac you can buy and not too unreasonably priced given it's spec.
It's hard to test price when all your testers get the hardware for free.
Re:Three Design Hacks from Apple
by malvosenior on Friday January 14, 2011 @01:51PM
(#2104881)
There were also manufacturing defects that caused "cracks" in most cubes. Also, OS X was barely usable at the time. The platform was much more robust when the Mini came out.
It can seem a bit scattered too:
iOS 3.2. It's a rotation lock switch! iOS 4.2. It's a mute switch! IOS 4.3. Oh whatever, you can pick.
Re:Three Design Hacks from Apple
by Stormbringer on Friday January 14, 2011 @02:57PM
(#2105164)
Good example. I missed the rotation lock feature for a week before I discovered that you could still get that feature, just in a completely different place.
If the iPad was a website, I'd say it had a bad case of 'mystery meat' navigation.
I think this is one of the key elements missing in other places. Look at Microsoft's copy of the iPod (poo flavour Zune), or RIM's copy of the iPhone (the atrocious Storm).
But here's the thing, what we never know is how many iterations went on at Apple behind closed doors and over how many years.
Everybody else does their beta testing (alpha in some cases) in public, as well as subsequent iterations. You don't see those failed products from Apple, you don't see it till it has the rough corners knocked off.
On the other hand, just because it is highly polished doesn't mean it isn't a turd. The Cube was a thing of enormous, tremendous beauty, but still a colossal failure in the market-place. It's 'spiritual successor', the Mac mini is uglier in every way (except total size perhaps), but was a much greater commercial success.
Apple's willingness to throw out or challenge everything can be a weakness too, on numerous occasions they've changed the UI of some software and made it tangibly worse, made it harder to use. or just outright removed some useful functionality.