News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by panarky on Friday September 20, 2019 @10:36AM (#21027122)
Not the first time I've heard someone argue that state-sponsored agitprop is free speech, while suppressing it on a private platform is somehow dystopian.

Ignorance is strength?

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by human20190310 on Friday September 20, 2019 @11:41AM (#21027917)
I think part of the problem is that Twitter is rooted in American assumptions about propaganda that don't apply globally.

America isn't propaganda-free, of course, but there's enough competing/conflicting propaganda that things kind-of balance out. (Or at least historically they did; increased silo-ing is reducing exposure to conflicting opinions even here).

Opening the platform to countries like Saudi Arabia and China brings fully-functional propaganda operations into the global mix, for which there is no existing competition. Nobody really knows what to do about it.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by excursionist on Friday September 20, 2019 @11:50AM (#21028029)
Do these 'state-sponsored' accounts have a footer '- sponsored by X' in their posts? How are you determining what is state-sponsored?
Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by mastazi on Friday September 20, 2019 @10:03PM (#21033023)
> state-sponsored agitprop

as defined by the board of Twitter, Inc.? I stand by my "ignorance" then.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by vkou on Friday September 20, 2019 @11:29AM (#21027778)
State-sponsored agitprop bad, private, corporate-sponsored agitprop good.

Am I understanding the implications of your post correctly?

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by WhatIsDukkha on Friday September 20, 2019 @12:11PM (#21028276)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

I think is pretty directly relevant to your "question"?

So unless we deal with the problem of Coca Cola being on twitter we can't deal with state sponsored bots?

Your question seems insincere and merely aimed at morally confusing the issue to no useful purpose.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by vkou on Friday September 20, 2019 @12:41PM (#21028613)
How on Earth is pointing out the hypocrisy of censoring paid propaganda by a state actor, but not by a corporate actor whataboutism? This is an incredibly relevant issue.

And we're not even trying to 'deal with the problem of Coca Cola being on Twitter'. The whole raison d'etre for Twitter's existence is dissemination of paid propaganda by corporate actors. It's what keeps the lights on at Twitter! Ads, promoted tweets, and other forms of paid speech.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by WhatIsDukkha on Friday September 20, 2019 @01:33PM (#21029209)
If the difference between a State and a Corporation is that muddled in your mind it's your issue not the rest of ours.

It's a critical part of being a discerning person to be able to BOTH say how things are similar and how they differ.

You seem to have no test for discerning how Coca Cola and the Russian government differ.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by vkou on Friday September 20, 2019 @02:49PM (#21029974)
For someone who doesn't live in Russia, the difference is academic, and they are far more similar, than they are different.

Actually, now that I think about it - one key difference is that shitty sugary drinks have killed more Americans then the Russian government did.

Another is that corporations buying candidates, by virtue of sponsoring their political campaigns have done more to undermine, subvert, and corrupt democracy than the Kremlin could ever dream of. You say the Russians have improperly 'influenced' elections? China astroturfs their global image? Please contrast that to to both the effort expended by, and the rewards gained by the fossil fuel industry, in 'influencing' elections, and astroturfing its global image.

Everyone's getting their knickers in a twist because some Trump staffer had some meetings with the Russian government - yet half the politicans in Washington are regurgitating talking points straight from a corporate press release.

But I suppose propaganda from the former is kosher, because they have a clear profit motive for it, eh?

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by cameronbrown on Friday September 20, 2019 @03:47PM (#21030489)
> Actually, now that I think about it - one key difference is that shitty sugary drinks have killed more Americans then the Russian government did.

The difference is agency. The people that chose to drink those drinks were able to make that decision, not helpless to some corporation.

You don't get to choose not to be assassinated by a Russian agent.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by vkou on Friday September 20, 2019 @05:41PM (#21031597)
That's a load of crock. By that same argument, since you have the agency to think for yourself and vote however you want, foreign propaganda should have zero impact on our elections.

I also don't have any choice in whether or not I personally get to deal with the negative social impacts of overconsumption of sugary drinks, overextraction of fossil fuels, or politicians bought by the healthcare cartels. I have to live with all of it.

Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by cameronbrown on Saturday September 21, 2019 @04:54PM (#21037877)
Partially, yeah. I do think that. Responsibility stops with the voter. The way we combat misinformation is with more information (like fact checks and advertiser transparency) and never censorship.
Re:Twitter discloses 10k accounts suspended for fomenting po... by cameronbrown on Friday September 20, 2019 @11:30AM (#21027800)
Prove that it's state sponsored. The point is, we can't. Not without Twitter sharing their data and methodologies. I've heard too many horror stories about being axed from the internet by a faceless corporation to accept their judgement blindly.