News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by darpa_escapee on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:15PM (#21010301)
Not really, it's a very old observation. For example, Cicero observed that "whoever gives his labor for money sells himself and puts himself in the rank of slaves"

And there are many types of slavery that are not chattel slavery.

Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by pmiller2 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:16PM (#21012265)
> And there are many types of slavery that are not chattel slavery.

Exactly! The sort of slavery being referenced here is "wage slavery," and it derives straight from Cicero's line of thinking. The idea here is that the vast majority of humans in a developed economy need to work. In particular, people without the resources to start a business themselves have to work for someone else. Although there is theoretically a choice of employers (there may not in fact be due to locality of the labor market), one nonetheless has to work for someone else, selling their time. If one wants to survive, one is not free to leave one's job.

This lack of freedom is the essential notion of wage slavery. That some wage slaves are better off than others is irrelevant: house slaves in the American South were often treated better and had better working conditions than field hands, but they were still slaves.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_slaveryhttps://en.wikiped...

Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by veggieburglar on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:32PM (#21010452)
So said Cicero, who was born into a wealthy family of property owners.
Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:36PM (#21010490)
So, people who both owned slaves and employed laborers, and were in a position to see the equivalence, but lacked the identity-group reasons either slaves or laborers would have to see an illusionary difference?
Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by veggieburglar on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:44PM (#21010576)
I’m having trouble parsing the second part of your response. Would you mind rephrasing it?

My point being that Cicero was free from a life of (physical) labor only because of the presence of these laborers/slaves. Property ownership enabled and paid for these intellectual or artistic pursuits.

Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by romwell on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:32PM (#21011098)
I think the parent's response is clear, and that they should not rephrase it. In fact, I'm having trouble rephrasing it (without having to explain what "group identity" is).

Here it goes, nevertheless.

People are social beings. We like to find "our" groups, and feel pride in being members of them. Examples of such groups: political parties, nationalities, religion, fans of a particular kind of music/artist/clothing style/tv show, hobby groups, etc).

Because of that, we feel bad when our groups are conflated; we feel it erases a part of our identity. Waged workers in this example feel pride in being not slaves, however nominal the distinction is.

This effect is even more pronounced because in a stratified society (which the Roman Empire was), as a waged worker, you could be confused for a slave, but not for a member of nobility. (We feel the most animosity when being taken to be a member of a group that resembles ours the most. Tell a Ukrainian that culturally, very little differentiates them from a Russian - and be prepared to be lectured on just how wrong you are.)

So, waged workers, then and now, would have reasons to vehemently identify themselves as "not slaves", and thus they would be biased in assessing the differences, seeing all of them as significant.

Ranks of nobility would have no such bias.

Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:55PM (#21011325)
That's probably a better explanation than I would have posted.
Re:Young People Are Going to Save Us All from Office Life by kentrado on Thursday September 19, 2019 @02:39AM (#21013868)
His background doesn't affect the truth of his statement.