News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by methodover on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @11:52PM (#21013123)
Gofast is just a weather balloon.

https://youtu.be/PLyEO0jNt6M

Gimbal is a jet. The perceived rotation is an artifact of the camera rotating on a gimbal.

https://youtu.be/4X1PRDbtiF0

Nimitz is also a jet. It’s far away, and blurry.

https://youtu.be/s1oTg0kxzDs

It would be really cool if these were alien spaceships. They’re likely not.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by hellofunk on Thursday September 19, 2019 @06:48AM (#21015030)
It's interesting to see you speak matter-of-factly about what they are, despite the Navy saying they are indeed unidentified.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by derefr on Thursday September 19, 2019 @11:19AM (#21017012)
For a military, "identifying" a craft is less about saying what something is, and more about saying who something is. If you know that something is a jet, but you can't recognize the make of it well-enough to know whose embassy to complain to for it being in your airspace, then it's still "unidentified."

It's sort of like a criminal investigation. If you know that "a tall, Caucasian male" is responsible for the crime, that's not worth issuing a formal finding about, because you still haven't identified a suspect to pursue. You have some details, but not enough to "go on."

(Also, many things that aren't jets try to pretend to be jets in various ways, many jets try to pretend to not be jets in various ways, and many jets try to pretend to be other jets in various ways. If you just see "a jet", you can't be sure which of these cases is in play. Identification involves finding a non-repudiable signature—a tell that indicates a particular make of device, that cannot be faked by any other currently-known device. Sort of like a (well-made) virus signature.)

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by hellofunk on Thursday September 19, 2019 @02:55PM (#21019384)
> For a military, "identifying" a craft is less about saying what something is, and more about saying who something is.

Except that the article says:

> And while officials said they don't know what the objects are

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by johnchristopher on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @04:16PM (#21009622)
So, anyone on HN knows what it's likely to really be ?
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by lend000 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:57PM (#21010693)
People on HN tend to be skeptical to a fault. In this case, even the usual skeptics just say "we can't rush to conclusions."[0]

When the Navy released this footage and the story with a number of highly credible witnesses and recorded sensor video, I decided to be more open minded when there was such unexplainable evidence of things that I couldn't possibly dream up a terrestrial explanation for. My guess is that it was a machine operated by something from a different system, far more advanced than us, observing us from a distance similar to how we might observe the Sentinelese. I suspect some percentage of UFO reports that don't have such solid evidence are also valid and related.

Everyone on HN says "of course we're not alone in this vast universe!" but when confronted with possible evidence of them being here, monitoring us, it's a bit too much for their reality. Perhaps it's the feeling of loss of free will and self determinism that it implies.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Nimitz_UFO_incident#Skepti...

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by olliej on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:08PM (#21010806)
Do you have any evidence to suggest that there isn’t a terrestrial explanation? You’ve gone straight from “I don’t know what this is” to “I think it’s something from another system monitoring us”.

That’s an astonishingly large leap to a very major conclusion. As such it requires a substantial amount of compelling evidence. Short low quality video is not that, so I assume you have either additional data about the events, or you are already in the “government hushing up aliens” group - in which case you aren’t actually being open minded, you’re simply anchoring to anything that supports your preexisting viewpoint.

Nothing particularly wrong with that - that’s human nature - but it’s important to recognize that what you’re demonstrating is not being open minded

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by lend000 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:38PM (#21011690)
I would have left a very similar comment a few years ago. As you said, it's human nature to hold on to beliefs, especially when those beliefs strongly define their worldview. Read the wiki link -- it isn't just a video, and the sensor that took it is ~$3mm a pop.

I could direct you to find some links describing how many other "potentially life-friendly" systems are thought to exist in the galaxy, let alone the observable universe, and then do some math on the odds of us being the most advanced. Once receptive to the idea of there likely being at least one more-advanced space-faring civilization in our galaxy, then what? Should we blindly bow down to alien overlords whenever we can't explain something? No, but we should certainly investigate it with an open mind when there is credibility (e.g. the most advanced military on Earth releases a WTF video and sailor/pilot testimony) and the null hypothesis ("we are alone and this phenomena is something we can explain with existing science.") can't be proven.

In my case, I have some family anecdata which is worthless to you, but which I had dismissed until this video came out along with a similar one from the Chilean Navy, and I decided I lean toward these being intelligent phenomena not from this system. I consider most of the examples in the following video to be on the credible side, and I'm fascinated by the implications of it all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaSY2Zc0goQ

It saddens me that science-oriented folks would shut themselves out from something so interesting (and statistically probable by mainstream estimates), but again, just human nature.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by olliej on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @08:23PM (#21011975)
What?

The null hypothesis is not “we are alone”. Nor is it particularly relevant here.

We have a small object over a short period of time with an expensive sensor - which does not mean high quality: FLIR systems are expensive at low resolution.

The options are:

* it is a terrestrial object that we have never seen before

* it is a terrestrial object we have seen before, just not in this environment

* it is a monitoring device from another system

Instead of doing the sensible thing and saying what terrestrial things could this be and demonstrating it is not them, you have gone straight to “someone with lots of money couldn’t determine what it was, so it must be aliens”. You then go another step of evidenceless assertions: that it is here to “monitor” us. Let’s take a hypothetical position that you are correct on the first count, the object comes from an intelligent species outside of the system: what is your evidence it is sent to monitor us? Why not be a probe along the lines of the various interplanetary probes we’ve sent out? That is a one way video camera to see what’s there, with no significant advance knowledge.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by lend000 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @08:51PM (#21012147)
> Instead of doing the sensible thing and saying what terrestrial things could this be and demonstrating it is not them

That was already done by the Navy before releasing this, not to mention many other skeptics. Do you have a new idea? I read some on another HN thread active on this topic. The most credible one seems like advanced EW jammers to produce a bogie on the atflir video, but it doesn't explain the visual sightings or simultaneous passive radar sightings with atflir readings. And to my knowledge, EW is used on lower frequencies where long distance radar typically operates; not sure if it even works on IR. If you've ever worked on defense projects, you may know they aren't exactly hotbeds of innovation these days, so while it is possible that they could have independently come up with a propulsion based on new physics and misdirected other branches of the government about it, that seems as unlikely to me as extraterrestrials do to you. Nonetheless, this being a domestic highly-classified craft is another option you can choose to believe.

As I already said, the monitoring part is just my guess -- and there were plenty of steps in between seeing this video and coming to that conclusion. The only thing I would try to persuade anyone of is that it wasn't made by humans. Which has pretty profound implications as it is. I do encourage you to do your own research (the two links I posted are a good place to start). Don't nitpick just so you can stick your head back in the sand (you're clearly aware of human nature, now fight it!). I'm no expert and I'm no more qualified to decipher the likely incomprehensible intentions of an advanced civilization than you are. However, I do try to be open minded and I'm fascinated by this, and compelled by the amount of evidence that already exists.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by opwieurposiu on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:35PM (#21010488)
My pet theory is that they are mylar balloons launched by russian submarines. The subs launch the balloons as radar targets to elicit a response from the navy. Then the subs gather intel on our radars, response time, order of battle, etc.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by greedo on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:03PM (#21011404)
The Russian sub fleet is in dismal shape currently. And launching something like this would probably result in detection and tracking of the sub. Most of these videos were off the West Coast near San Diego, in a weapons training area, so that would be like poking the wasp nest with a stick.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by aalleavitch on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:41PM (#21010546)
This isn't the most unreasonable idea, are their movements really consistent with balloons, though?
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by tomatotomato37 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:16PM (#21010918)
The upper atmosphere is a mess of violent winds, so it wouldn't be out of the ordinary. Don't forget a weightless balloon is a lot more sensitive to turbulence than a multi-ton computer-stabilized fighter jet, and those winds can already drop a multi-hundred-ton 747 by tens of feet.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by aalleavitch on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:32PM (#21011109)
But they’ve been seen traveling against the wind at high speeds
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by js8 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:00PM (#21010728)
They flew towards it, it was static, and then it rapidly shifted to the left as they overtook it close from the right.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by aalleavitch on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:35PM (#21011136)
It wasn’t static, though, it was traveling at Mach 0.5
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by klatuu on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:28PM (#21011617)
There is more than one incident. In one incident (2004 Nimitz FLIR1, west coast), the object is static and then initiates non-newtonian acceleration. In the next (GIMBAL, undated, east coast), the same behavior of static hovering with non-newtonian motion.

In another, your example (2015 GOFAST, west coast) a slightly different elongated object is cruising at Mach 0.5 at low altitude, close to the water.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by ak217 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:31PM (#21011630)
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by johnchristopher on Thursday September 19, 2019 @04:05AM (#21014273)
Well. I like that.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by quakeguy on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:07PM (#21010217)
Black projects by foreign powers? Idk really, the flight specs (if believable) are insane. So common sense says reading/sensory data error.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by aalleavitch on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:11PM (#21010267)
That wouldn't make any sense, though, because they've been detected by multiple different types of sensors and apparently very frequently. Unless someone were making these errors appear on purpose it wouldn't be reasonable to expect a software/hardware error.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by Zardoz84 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:10PM (#21010239)
on both sensors at same time, getting the same fake signal at the same spot ?
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by voldacar on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:51PM (#21011792)
Yeah and the pilots conversing about it in real time as well. It's definitely a much higher-quality datum than most so-called UFO videos for sure
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by lazyjones on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @08:44PM (#21012100)
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by ipunchghosts on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @04:29PM (#21009773)
What is with all these links to "To the Stars Academy." I just don't get what that organization is trying to do.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by logjammin on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @04:37PM (#21009889)
It's bizarre. What's with the name? The bits don't fit together. Sounds like a low-rent acting school. If it's an an academy, can I take classes?

And it's ... The Blink-182 guy?

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by cududa on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:14PM (#21011489)
They’ve always been huge alien conspiracy theorists. They have multiple songs on the topic and joke about it at their shows
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by yasp on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:14PM (#21010295)
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by i_call_solo on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:07PM (#21010216)
Listen to Tom Delonge on The Joe Rogan Experience to see just how crazy he and that organization are.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5n_3mnJfHzY

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by rozab on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @05:53PM (#21010660)
I stopped watching when he said they were in the process of building a time machine. I can't even imagine how crazy it gets later on.

I can't believe these people are being given a platform. They weren't the first to come out with the videos, were they?

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by 7532yahoogmail on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:44PM (#21011231)
Wouldn't another plausible explanation be someone has hacked the radar? Because then implausible movement and speed would be explainable.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by klatuu on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:11PM (#21011464)
That hypothesis and also video/optical/signal "lens flares" and other such technical glitch theories have been discussed widely.

The reason none of that holds up is because of the way advanced "sensor fusion" and direct observers with the naked eye have all agreed and converged on highly detailed accounts from multiple angles.

You might imagine that "sensor fusion" involves some centralized control plane that collects and controls the redistributed captures at a focal choke point, where maybe the NSA (or a foreign APT implant, or some such high tech evil-doer) could sneak in and spoof some deep fake concoction into the mix, but these are fault tolerant systems, including direct observations from boots on the ground in visual contact with the objects. You have personnel with ordinary binoculars. You have vehicles with weapons systems that expect jamming and hostile environments. Sensor fusion is one tool, and not the only tool in the kit.

They have ships with eyes in multiple spectrum bands, especially radio, microwave, IR and broad daylight. People looking at unfused radar, sending planes to a radar return, and then seeing and following the object by visual flight rules.

This isn't a situation where a single point of failure introduces doubt. In fact, it is the very opposite: multiple independent sources of high integrity, at least if you trust The U.S. Navy.

Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by admax88q on Sunday September 22, 2019 @08:55AM (#21041146)
To some degree the sensor fusion actually helps the case for sensor malfunction. It would explain why it was detected by multiple "independent" systems if in fact those systems are not independent.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by cududa on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @07:13PM (#21011478)
I’m going to guess someone in the military thought of this and checked.
Re:The US Navy just confirmed these UFO videos are the real ... by anewguy9000 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @06:26PM (#21011038)
ugh, these videos are as old as time but every few months since 2015 a new article comes out with a clickbait headline referencing the same thing. there are a few sources that have reported on this objectively (nbc sandiego isnt one), if you look.