Ask HN: Please give us feedback on our (anti-social) tool thinkery.me
We wanted an app that extends your brain by:
- making it super fast to add new things, urls, todos, just throwing everything at it that is in your brain
- automatically extracting relevant content like text, audio, video, images (using oembed but also scraping the page identifying the relevant content)
- quickly finding your notes with instant-search
- keeping things private or making them public (to share them on twitter, facebook)...
My public things: http://thinkery.me/nader
Example of extracted page (truncated due to copyright reasons, private things dont get truncated): http://thinkery.me/nader/4d2ec7f67477595c14000000
Example of oembed content: http://thinkery.me/nader/4d245b10747759f448010000
We're not perfectly sure what direction to take. What we're sure of is that this needs a working mobile version but for the rest...would you rather focus on making the app more social or add features like:
- assigning things to / inviting other people (@-syntax?)?
- dragging'n'dropping of images into it?
- create filters so you can only display private / public things?
- extracting even more content by aggregating similar things?
- automatically retrieve tweets you favorited?
It would be awesome and very much appreciated if you gave your thoughts, feedback or posted any bugs you encounter. Also say if this is a tool you would use or what is missing so you would use it.
Looking forward to it!
PS: There is a delicious importer in case you want to try that out: http://thinkery.me/delicious.php
Some points of feedback:
- The tagging functionality is kind of buried and isn't labeled at all. I'm not sure how prominent you want to make it, but here are two thoughts: you could allow for dragging of an entry to a tag on the left (this would be even more useful if there was a way to add a new tag on the left) or you could add tagging functionality before the edit page (like above or below the preview panel on the right)
- I put in the wrong pw on the delicious importer but didn't see any error message.
- Again, I'm not sure if this is a direction you want to go, but it seems like there might be some interesting collaborative elements you could incorporate; like logged-in users being able to leave notes on public items
- Mobile would be nice, as would a browser plugin or desktop app that allows me to dump in content easily.
Most of my feedback would put you on a path to be more of a bookmarking service and maybe you want to leave things more open than that. Either way, congrats for making a great app and good luck going forward!
The hashtagging of absolutely everything works really well #like
I like the idea of being invited to "Login to your brain" ;-) #interface
The facility to copy/paste in non-media files as well as text would be nice... obviously this takes up more bandwidth but that's something you can easily charge for. #suggestion
Whilst I very rarely use them, I think a screencast demoing the sites functions would be a good idea #suggestion
More social probably helps you promote the app, but your suggested feature list sounds a lot more useful
Also, like a number of people I seem to have had small problems with register/login (specifically the validations advise email addresses are incorrect if you paste/autocomplete them into place). #bug
Delicious importer doesn't seem to work with Yahoo IDs. Not sure if there's a way around that #bug
Recommendations:
* Use more width for your design. It does have too much white space on the right side and therefore too few space for your content (Firefox 3.6.13 on Mac)
* There is text beneath your footer
* your logo on /titncs is blurry
* Maybe you could add an "processing" message, especially for amazon links
In addition to the Ubuntu issue already pointed out, the copyright overlay is blocking the bottom of your pages on various browsers, specifically "Get your own thinkery now >>" on the main page and "embed.ly" on the About page.
Tagging and display looks very useful. Overall I like it, and I'll be watching in the future for the mobile apps.
1. If appropriate, deep integration with facebook, twitter, linkedin etc, not only to ease registration process but also for sharing content(in both directions)and other social features.
2. Utilize FB API to provide a social network around your service and let users share/comment/discuss/rate/etc. about your public things.Provide top rated/discussed thinkeries somewhere on your home page.
3. Instead of making it just public and private, provide access levels - public, friends, private, customized, etc.
4. Mobile application for quick/anytime/anywhere thinkering.
5. A search interface for searching public thinkeries and adding them to your own collection.
6. Facility to add thinkeries through SMS, email, chat etc. example - SMS your new design/startup idea to your thinkery using short code or forward an intersting e-mail to your thinkery. That leads to another idea that e-mail and chats can also be a kind of thinkery items.
First we need to fix some bugs though. Did you get the error when you hit register or at another point?
Also...when I start to add a bookmarklet and click "cancel", it takes me to an error page.
I think I'd rather not lose the page I'm on when I bookmartlet it, but I haven't used it enough to decide. If I click cancel I definitely don't want to. Maybe a new tab?
You can try it out without registering if the main input field works, it's got lazy registration :)
Otherwise, just looking through it - like the layout and the general concept is intriguing. To answer your question of focus, I like the idea of filters or aggregating additional content. (But please let me choose whether or not to accept those new content streams.)
EDIT: When I register from the homepage, the form works. Previously I tried to click register while viewing your sample Nader page.
http://imgur.com/aKDjW
Firefox 3.6 on Ubuntu screen resolution 1280x768
One minor bug I encountered: If I enter "I like #foo" and save it, it is filed under the tag #foo. If I then edit that item to be "I like #food" it stays filed under it's original tag, #foo, rather than being moved to #food.
Edit: edited to clarify bug description.
I've been using a combination of tumblr/facebook-status-line to do these kind of things.
This is much much better.
More comments later :)
I don't see anything new.
PS: I'm bitten by the type of services you note above, my "brain" is stored locally on my browser backed up by myself, I'm fine with what I have..
Did you check out the content extraction, instant-search or posting a youtube url for example?
Thanks for the feedback.
http://thinkery.me/nader/4d2b4a6e747759286c000000
or something like an amazon product: http://thinkery.me/nader/4d1d0ec2747759af42000000